The Dictatorship
Progressives need to build media that competes and wins for people. Here’s how.
Amid the sea of conservative talk radio, I’ve been working as a progressive in independent media for nearly two decades hosting a popular political talk program, “The David Pakman Show.” During this time, I’ve observed a shifting media landscape that has left many politically progressive content creators — and our audiences — frustrated, confused and sometimes defeated and despondent. But I’ve also witnessed firsthand that there is a path forwardeven in this age of mass misinformationecho chambers and reactionary politics.
As misinformation and media illiteracy have plagued the already fractured American political system, much of the left would like to think this phenomenon is confined to right-wing bubbles. But progressives must grapple with the new reality: The right’s echo machine has been thriving among all online audiences and is spreading. In a study of popular online shows active in 2024the results showed that nine of the 10 most popular shows were right-leaning, accounting for at least 197 million total followers and subscribers. Of these right-leaning shows, only four are categorized as “News and Politics” on Apple Podcasts. Additionally, 72% of 111 supposedly nonpolitical shows were found to have an ideological bent to the right.
There is a path forward, even in this age of mass misinformation, echo chambers and reactionary politics.
According to Pew Research survey from August 2024, ahead of the election, about 1 in 5 Americans said they regularly get their news from social media. President Donald Trump and his allies effectively leveraged nontraditional platforms — podcasts, TikTok and influencer-driven content — to reach an audience feeling economically insecure and culturally alienated. This was especially prevalent among young male voters ages 18-29 who gravitated toward figures that emerged through gaming, fitness, financial advice and lifestyle platforms that seamlessly wove together political messages into content young men already enjoy, often offering an entry point to conservative ideology. Progressive voices, by contrast, too often relied on late-stage symbolic gestures or vague messaging that failed to resonate. In the recent election, even the too little came too late, with efforts to create a left-of-center media ecosystem equivalent to that of the right starting far too late to make an impact.
While progressive media doesn’t need to mimic right-wing tactics directly, as the most recent podcast conversation between California Gov. Gavin Newsom and right-wing activist Charlie Kirk would suggest — indeed, that would be a mistake — we can’t ignore the ecosystem entirely. What we must do is understand, engage and address why these online and independent platforms are so effective.
One of the key lessons I’ve learned is simple, yet critical: Progressive media succeeds most powerfully and meaningfully when it clearly connects politics to people’s real lives.
This is not about celebrity endorsements chasing viral moments — tactics that corporate media increasingly leans into but often end up ringing hollow. Instead, it means clearly articulating how issues like health care, climate change and economic policy tangibly affect the day-to-day lives of our respective audiences.
A driving reason audiences are drawn to independent media is authenticity — or at least the perception of it.
Right-wing media figures often project a relatable image, speaking directly to their audiences. They’re unafraid to go off script and debate anyone who shows up to the fight. Regardless of if you agree with their messaging, their methods are instructive.
The Trump campaign effectively created an environment of casual hanging out and parasocial relationships, where Trump and JD Vance themselves would appear in long-form unstructured conversations on a variety of programs, including Joe Rogan’s podcast, the Nelk Boys’ channel and Lex Fridman’s podcast.
Progressive media succeeds most powerfully and meaningfully when it clearly connects politics to people’s real lives.
The contrasting approach from Democratic candidates — with the exception of a select few like Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt. — left much to be desired. Whereas Trump appeared on less overtly political shows with more of a lifestyle and pop culture bent, Democrats’ were less frequent guests in these arenas and almost always had a feeling of stiffness and micromanagement.
For progressive media, authenticity means acknowledging people’s genuine concerns about the economy, health care, misinformation and education, and providing real answers while grappling with disagreements, mistakes or unintentional policy outcomes, as opposed to spewing patronizing talking points.
My audience has gravitated toward nuanced analyses of how policy decisions — from health care to tax cuts — directly impact their finances, health or personal freedoms. When the corporate media landscape increasingly feels overwhelming, overly sensational, or gives a feeling of talking at rather than to audiences, authenticity breaks down and audiences disengage or find new sources of news.
There was a short video that went viral just prior to the election where I explained to a young Trump-supporting podcast host that, despite his confidence that China was cutting checks to the United States for tariffs placed on its products, it was actually American companies that paid the tariffs. This video ultimately accrued more than 20 million views, in part due to its simplicity, salience and authentic dialogue. Those 60 seconds from a 90-minute conversation corrected just one piece of misinformation, and did so in a way that connected directly to anyone who buys or produces goods — essentially everyone in our economy — and made them realize that Americans pay the tariffs, not China.
If we truly want progressive ideas to break through, I believe we must focus less on competing through spectacle and more on respecting and addressing the very real concerns that brought our audiences to seek us out in the first place.
In fact, despite the overwhelming noise of the mainstream media, independent progressive media has shown robust growth precisely because it offers what many mainstream outlets often don’t: substance, respect for intelligence, and a genuine dialogue. Platforms like mine that attract moderate, left and right-leaning voters demonstrate daily that audiences aren’t merely looking for confirmation of their existing beliefs; they’re hungry for clarity and honesty.
Politics isn’t consumed in isolation — it’s absorbed within the broader fabric of culture. Rather than ignoring this, progressive voices can thoughtfully engage these areas without co-opting them cynically. Viewers and listeners aren’t looking for a left-wing version of right-wing media tactics; they’re looking for content that treats them as thoughtful individuals. By offering relatable, well-reasoned perspectives that resonate on a human level, progressives can effectively reach audiences that are currently underserved or misled.
Despite widespread cynicism about the media and politics, I’m optimistic. We don’t have to accept misinformation as inevitable. Part of the solution lies in fostering critical thinking and media literacy — but another essential part is delivering media that’s meaningful, practical and directly connected to people’s daily lives. The path to a more informed, less polarized America lies in precisely this kind of engagement.
David Pakman
David Pakman is the host of “The David Pakman Show” and the author of “The Echo Machine: How Right-Wing Extremism Created a Post-Truth America.”
The Dictatorship
Trump to ‘kick off’ America’s 250th event after berating artists who backed out
President Donald Trump will join the opening ceremony of the White House-backed “Great American State Fair” on the National Mall, the organizer said Saturday, just hours after Trump excoriated music artists who dropped out of the event.
Danielle Alvarez, a spokesperson for the White House initiative Freedom 250, said in a statement that Trump will “personally kick off this historic celebration on Wednesday, June 24 in an opening ceremony celebrating America’s 250th birthday.”
Earlier in the day, Trump had railed against artists who distanced themselves from the event celebrating the country’s 250th anniversary, saying in a Truth Social post that they “get paid far too much money” and “aren’t happy.” He said he was considering replacing them with the “number one attraction anywhere in the world”: himself.
The artists — many of whom have had successful decades-long careers — are “getting ‘the yips’” about having to perform at the event, he wrote. “So I am thinking about bringing the Number One Attraction anywhere in the World, the man who gets much larger audiences than Elvis in his prime, and he does so without a guitar, the man who loves our Country more than anyone else, and the man who some say is the Greatest President in History (THE GOAT!), DONALD J. TRUMP, to take the place of these highly paid, Third Rate ‘Artists,’ and give a major speech, rallying the Country forward like I have done ever since being President.”
Almost all the artists who were included in the lineup for the two-week event have said they will not perform, citing its political affiliation. Freedom 250 threatens to overshadow programs organized by America250a nonpartisan organization established by Congress in 2016 to organize events this year commemorating the 250th anniversary of the founding of the United States. The newly founded Trump-backed group has caused confusion for celebrities and corporate sponsors who intended to participate in the official semiquincentennial group.
“We’ve got incredible momentum,” a spokeswoman for America250 said in a statement. “Already, America250 has shown up in some of the biggest moments in culture and sports, from ringing in the New Year in Times Square and appearing in the Rose Parade, to the NFL Playoffs and Super Bowl.”
The artists who have not pulled out the Trump-headlined event — including Vanilla Ice and Flo Rida — have been roundly criticized for their participation.
Clarissa-Jan Lim is a breaking news reporter for MS NOW. She was previously a senior reporter and editor at BuzzFeed News.
The Dictatorship
Trump’s doctor declares him ‘fully fit’ and blames ‘frequent handshaking’ for bruising
President Donald Trump’s physician declared him in “excellent health,” but recommended the president lose weight and exercise more following his latest physical exam.
“Cognitive and physical performance are excellent,” Navy Capt. Sean Barbabella wrote in his report released on Friday. “He is fully fit to carry out all duties of the Commander-in-Chief and Head of State.”
Trump —the oldest person to be sworn in as president, who turns 80 next month — showed “strong cardiac, pulmonary, neurological, and overall physical function,” the doctor wrote. “His demanding daily schedule, including multiple high-level meetings, public engagements, and regular physical activity, continues to support his overall well-being.”
The president’s weight was recorded as 238 lbs, 14 lbs heavier than what was reported in his April 2025 physical. Barbabella said he provided guidance to Trump on his diet, as well as advice to take low-dose aspirin, increase physical activity and lose weight.
Trump underwent his annual physical exam on Tuesday at Walter Reed National Military Medical Center. Afterward, he wrote on Truth Social“Everything checked out PERFECTLY.”

In his memo, Barbabella, who previously diagnosed Trump with chronic venous insufficiency, noted swelling in the president’s lower leg “with improvement from last year.” He attributed bruising on Trump’s hands to be “consistent with minor soft tissue irritation related to frequent handshaking.”
The swelling in Trump’s legs and bruising on his hands have been the subject of increasing scrutiny and speculation about the aging president’s fitness for office. The White House has attributed the bruising on the president’s hands to his frequent handshaking, as Barbabella noted in his latest report.
Trump has also appeared to nod off during public appearances. He has dismissed criticism of those incidents, saying he was merely “resting his eyes.”
Trump often boasts about the results of his medical exams, saying he has “aced” cognitive tests and that “the numbers were perfect” on his physical. He has frequently insisted that he is fit to serve as president, but his mental acuity for office has been called into question.
The latest physical, the third of his second term, took place amid mounting questions and public concerns about his health.
Clarissa-Jan Lim is a breaking news reporter for MS NOW. She was previously a senior reporter and editor at BuzzFeed News.
The Dictatorship
Just let Knicks fans have this moment, Trump. Stay away.
In addition to threatening to bomb U.S. ally Oman and declaring that he doesn’t “care about the midterms,” President Donald Trump made a very different sort of surprise announcement at his Cabinet meeting Wednesday: “I think I’ll be going to one of the [NBA Finals] games.”
Specifically, the president said he had been invited by “numerous people,” including New York Knicks owner James Dolanto attend the team’s first finals home game since 1999, the same year Dolan took majority ownership over the franchise.
Although presidents have sporadically attended MLB’s World Series since the early 20th century, no president has appeared at the NBA finals — not even Barack Obama, who famously added a basketball court to the tennis grounds on the White House South Lawn. Trump would be the first to do so, just as he was the first sitting president to attend a Super Bowl in 2025.
The news has, unsurprisingly, provoked strong reactions — most of them missing the point.

New York Gov. Kathy Hochul stepped on a metaphorical rake when she implied to reporters Thursday that Trump probably couldn’t name “the starting lineup of the 1993 Championship team” (the last Knicks title was in 1973). MAGA commentariat quickly seized the opportunity, mocking Hochul and amplifying a clip of Trump attending the Knicks’ Game 3 loss in the 1994 NBA Finals. Indeed, New York magazine found Trump has appeared in the “celebrity row” at Madison Square Garden numerous times over the decades, in keeping with his lifelong efforts at social climbing among the city’s elites.
But that’s all this is to Trump: A chance to be the ultimate celebrity in a room packed with them, at the Garden’s hottest ticket in decades.
To Knicks fans like myself, the team’s first Finals appearance in 27 years is a priceless and fleeting moment. It’s for us. To root happily after the mostly miserable decades of Dolan’s ownership, which The New York Times described as “so consistently and convincingly lifeless that perma-despair seemed utterly normal.” To wax nostalgic for the great Patrick Ewing-led teams of the 1990s, who came oh-so-close to hoisting the Larry O’Brien trophy during the decade when Michael Jordan and the Chicago Bulls won six titles. To allow ourselves to believe the impossible dream could happen: watching Jalen Brunson and his teammates parading down the Canyon of Heroes among cascading ticker tape in mid-June.
That’s all this is to Trump: A chance to be the ultimate celebrity in a room packed with them, at the Garden’s hottest ticket in decades.
And while there are surely Trump supporters among the Knickerbockers’ fanbase, I can’t imagine even they’re clamoring to see the president peacocking at the Garden. Knicks fans understand what a precious instant this is and why it should not be drawn into Trump’s toxic orbit for the time it takes to play one best-of-seven series.
The joy surrounding the Knicks’ improbable run has vibes in this city running so high that native New Yorkers in blue and orange are being friendly to one another and making idle chitchat on the streets. It’s weird.
Even The Ringer’s Bill Simmons — typically a New York sports team hater — has cheered on the Knicks’ run as an unambiguously feel-good story for the league and has seemed genuinely happy on his podcast about the giddiness and anticipation among New York’s long-suffering basketball die-hards.
New York City is historically a basketball town. It has produced a disproportionate number of Hall of Famers and a culture of street and playground basketball often emulated but never duplicated. And in a region with almost a dozen major professional sports franchises (some, like the Yankeesare passionately hated by millions of New Yorkers), the Knicks are the only team that unites pretty much everyone. (Sorry, Brooklyn Nets, it just never really caught on.)

Israel Daramola aptly elucidated loyal Knicks fans’ predicament in the Defector: “In between those various eras was a lot of executive mismanagement, beefs, suffering, the worst contracts you’ve ever seen, an arena that has showcased the powers of the surveillance stateand an owner who takes joy in being awful, because no one likes his blues band or whatever. All of which is to say: I know people find the Knicks annoying and New York City insufferable, but dammit, they deserve this moment.”
Win or lose, we know this feeling isn’t meant to last.
Is it too much to ask for the historically unpopular president — who regularly disparages this city, made a big show of departing it and will never forgive it because it never loved him back — to not divert the spotlight, just this one time?
It ultimately won’t change the results on the court either way, and a Secret Service-locked-down Madison Square Garden for one night won’t spoil the party. But the Trumpness in the air would be an unwelcome energy in an atmosphere in which even the most cynical New Yorkers have briefly become wide-eyed, joyful fanatics.
This doesn’t need to be a morality play. Just do us a solid and stay away, Florida Man.
Anthony L. Fisher is a senior editor and opinion columnist for MS NOW.
-
Politics1 year agoFormer ‘Squad’ members launching ‘Bowman and Bush’ YouTube show
-
The Dictatorship1 year agoLuigi Mangione acknowledges public support in first official statement since arrest
-
Politics1 year agoFormer Kentucky AG Daniel Cameron launches Senate bid
-
Uncategorized2 years ago
Bob Good to step down as Freedom Caucus chair this week
-
The Dictatorship1 year agoPete Hegseth’s tenure at the Pentagon goes from bad to worse
-
The Josh Fourrier Show2 years agoDOOMSDAY: Trump won, now what?
-
Politics1 year agoBlue Light News’s Editorial Director Ryan Hutchins speaks at Blue Light News’s 2025 Governors Summit
-
The Dictatorship9 months agoMike Johnson sums up the GOP’s arrogant position on military occupation with two words




