The Dictatorship
Without insurance, immigrant patients may face unregulated ‘medical deportation’
ALLENTOWN, PA. (AP) — Junior Clase’s cluttered kitchen table paints a picture of his life in the United States. Scattered across it are bottles of deodorant and conditioner that he sends back to the Dominican Republic, a Spanish-language Bible and a plastic medical brace for his wife, Solibel Olaverria.
Olaverria began having intense headaches and vomiting five months after she joined her husband in the U.S. In the emergency room, she was diagnosed with a brain aneurysm; during surgery to stop it from rupturing, she suffered a stroke and was induced into a coma.
She left the couple’s Allentown row house in December 2022 and has yet to return. Clase worries she never will.
In February 2023, Clase said, hospital administrators suggested transporting his still-comatose wife to a facility back in the Dominican Republic – an option he refused.
“They told me that they could send her back to my country,” he said – even without his consent. “At that moment, she was missing a piece of her skull. … If they put her in an airplane or a helicopter, it was possible that she would die.”
Though the federal government is the only entity with the jurisdiction to remove people from the U.S., hospitals across the nation sometimes return uninsured noncitizen patients in need of long-term care to their countries of origin.
Advocates call this “medical deportation.” Hospitals and medical transport companies refer to it as “medical repatriation.” By either name, the practice exists in ethical and legal gray areas – without specific federal regulations, widespread public knowledge or a national tracking system.
Facing limited options for care, some immigrant patients and family members may voluntarily decide to continue treatment outside of the U.S. Other times, experts say, the process occurs without full consent.
Lori Nessel, a professor at Seton Hall University who supervised a 2012 report about medical repatriation, said the practice amounts to “private deportation.”
“They were essentially being deported,” she said, “but outside of the legal process for deportation, because there was no immigration court involved.”
While some foreign governments track these repatriations, data is inconsistent and doesn’t reflect whether patients wanted to return, felt they had no other option or were forced to leave.
Over the past two decades, academics, advocates and reporters have struggled to put a number on the phenomenon, which involves a tangled network of hospitals, air transport companies and consulates that work in different states and countries.
Since 2020, the Philadelphia-based Free Migration Project has tracked 19 cases of patients facing medical deportation, through referrals and a telephone hotline it runs. Six of those came in the first six months of 2025, from cities in Pennsylvania but also Florida, New Jersey and New York, according to Adrianna Torres-García, deputy director of the organization.
“We’ve had a higher volume of cases in the same span of time than any other given year,” Torres-García said. “It’s also more complex cases.”
Experts believe medical deportation happens more than tracking efforts account for, and some worry cases could now increase, given that the practice sits at the intersection of health care and immigration – two systems undergoing drastic change in the second Trump administration.
Early on, Olaverria was able to get treatment under a federal law that requires Medicare-participating hospitals to provide stabilizing care to anyone with an emergency condition, regardless of insurance, ability to pay or immigration status. Hospitals can then file for reimbursement through Emergency Medicaid.
But the tax and spending cut bill President Donald Trump signed in July significantly reduces how much the government will pay into Emergency Medicaid. The law also makes some immigrants, including refugees and asylees, ineligible for traditional Medicaid and Medicare.
Immigrants without legal status have long been ineligible for these programs, and even green card holders have to wait five years before they are eligible for Medicaid.
In effect, experts said, the changes will leave even more immigrants uninsured and provide less funding for emergency care if they need it.
“If immigrants are unable to get as much coverage, then they’re not going to be able to get as much care,” said Andrew Cohen, an attorney with Health Law Advocates, a public interest law firm in Boston. “That’s where medical deportations could really grow.”
The legal requirement to treat anyone with an emergency condition won’t go away, said Benjamin Sommers, a health policy researcher at Harvard University. But with the federal government paying less toward Emergency Medicaid, states could also decide to reduce how much funding goes to emergency care, shifting the burden to hospitals – or individuals.
Patients “get sent bills that they often can’t pay, that often are going to go to collections,” Sommers said, adding that some may even go bankrupt. “Sometimes we see hospitals diverting patients. … I think there’ll be more of that.”
Raymond Lahoud, a Pennsylvania lawyer who represents hospitals and health networks in cases related to immigration, said hospitals fulfill their obligations to treat all patients but often need to consider further options once those patients are stabilized.
“There comes a point where the hospital has done everything it medically could do, and now that person has to move on to their next step in rehabilitation or certain kinds of end-of-life care,” he said.
U.S. citizens might be discharged to other hospitals, long-term care facilities or their families. Noncitizens, with limited access to health insurance, might instead get sent to a facility in their country of origin.
Hospitals sometimes pay private medical transport companies to conduct repatriations and provide in-air care. These services routinely cost tens of thousands of dollars but may still be cheaper than long-term or indefinite care; in the U.S., inpatient hospital care cost an average of $3,132 per day in 2023, according to health policy research firm KFF.
“Unfortunately, it becomes a financial burden to the hospital,” said Craig Poliner, president of MedEscort, an Allentown-based medical air transport company that works with hospitals to facilitate medical repatriations.
Poliner insisted that MedEscort would never repatriate a patient without consent and said company officials work with hospitals to follow the American Medical Association’s discharge guidelines.
“The patients really do better in their own countries, in their own culture,” he said. “We’re not forcing anybody back. We convince them why we think it’s better. If we have the right approach, it usually resolves itself.”
However, advocates noted that immigration status, a lack of insurance, the injury or illness itself, unfamiliarity with the health care system and language barriers can hinder someone’s ability to give informed consent.
In 2013, John Sullivan, a social worker based in Tempe, Arizona, traveled to Mexico to study medical repatriation as part of a Fulbright scholarship. He interviewed patients who had been sent back, along with family members, health workers and Mexican officials.
Sullivan said the circumstances surrounding consent in some of those cases were “unclear.” “It was almost like migrants would describe feeling like they had no other choice,” he said.
Olaverria entered the U.S. on a temporary tourist visa, and when she sought treatment, she was uninsured. In the first days of March 2023, Clase said, hospital administrators gave him an ultimatum: Find care for his wife elsewhere, or they would follow through with her transfer to the Dominican Republic.
Clase said the only option he felt he had was to keep his wife where she was. He didn’t believe she would survive the flight to the Dominican Republic, and if she did, he didn’t trust that she’d receive the care she needed there. He couldn’t properly care for her at home, and she didn’t have insurance to cover the cost of another facility in the U.S.
Local advocates connected Clase with the Free Migration Project, which organized protests against Olaverria’s transfer. Outside the hospital, protesters carried homemade signs on neon-colored posters calling for an end to medical deportation.
After local media coverageClase said, hospital administrators agreed to hold off on the transfer if they could work together to find another long-term care option. The hospital did not respond to requests for comment.
Media coverage of Olaverria’s case helped bolster interest in a bill before the Philadelphia City Council to stop nonconsensual medical repatriations, and in December 2023, it became the nation’s first and only law banning the practice, according to experts.
The policy requires hospitals in the city to obtain patients’ written consent and provide information about their rights and options for care before transferring them out of the U.S. It also requires hospitals to determine whether patients are eligible for programs that could pay for their care – and, if so, help them enroll.
Philadelphia hospitals also must now report medical repatriations to the city’s Department of Public Health. Agency spokesman James Garrow said hospitals submitted five repatriation reports in 2024, the first full calendar year for which data was collected.
Claudia Martínez participated in the campaign to pass the law after her uncle faced medical repatriation. The personal photos, wedding memorabilia and Bible quotes that decorate her living room walls hang alongside a “Community Power Award” from the Pennsylvania Immigration Coalition.
“I don’t want anyone to go through what I went through,” Martínez said.
In May 2020, a motorcycle struck Martínez’s uncle, an immigrant from Guatemala. When Martínez arrived at the hospital, she found him comatose and intubated, with injuries that rendered him almost unrecognizable.
Weeks later, Martínez said, a hospital social worker asked for her uncle’s immigration status. She later learned the hospital and MedEscort planned to transfer him to a facility in Guatemala.
“I was in shock,” Martínez said. “He was intubated. … He was not in a condition to travel.”
She said she rejected the transfer in conversations with hospital officials and MedEscort, but Poliner said MedEscort got authorization for the repatriation from family members in Guatemala. Martínez disputes that.
Eventually, Martínez connected with the Free Migration Project, which organized a protest outside the hospital on the day of her uncle’s scheduled trans fer.
In the end, the medical deportation was scrapped. Ultimately, with the help of community advocates, Martinez’s uncle was able to access a form of state-sponsored insurance. He moved into a rehabilitation center and stayed for three years, until his insurance ran out.
In May 2024, his family decided it would be best for him to return to Guatemala to be at home with his wife. He can walk again but has significant memory impairments.
“He is someone who loves to joke,” Martínez said. “This, I think he didn’t lose.”
Consulates are often involved in the medical transport of their citizens, helping to secure travel documents and occasionally paying for airfare on less expensive commercial flights.
Between 2014 and 2024, the Mexican General Directorate of Consular Protection and Strategic Planning reported 8,227 medical repatriations; 328 of those took place in 2024. The data does not distinguish between patients who wanted to return and those who felt pressured or coerced.
“Sometimes the level of care that they are going to receive in their hometowns … is not going to compare to the one they receive here, and they know that – so it’s very rare that a patient says, ‘I want to leave,’” said one Mexican consular official, who did not want to be named to avoid repercussions in their ongoing work with hospitals.
If patients want to stay in the U.S., they may not know what options are available to them. Hospitals, too, may be unaware of alternatives, said Cohen, who runs a program that helps eligible immigrant patients access insurance.
In some states, immigrants who don’t qualify for federal insurance programs may be able to access certain state-funded programs instead.
“(Hospitals are) preemptively doing something that they wouldn’t even need to do if they knew about these pathways into better coverage,” Cohen said.
In May 2023, Olaverria was transferred into a long-term care facility in Allentown. Two months later, she woke up from the coma. She still cannot walk or use the bathroom on her own, and she can speak only a few words.
Later that year, Clase and his wife obtained medical deferred action, which allowed them to temporarily remain in the country. It also allowed Clase to get a work permit and Olaverria to access emergency medical assistance from the state.
Between working two jobs and attending church services three times a week, Clase keeps his ritual of visiting his wife every day. Flower bouquets rest on the bookshelf in her room.
He wipes her mouth, adjusts her neck and massages her curled-in hands. And he still tells her stories that can make her laugh.
For him, life outside this routine is virtually nonexistent. When he gets home each night, he sleeps and occasionally cries.
“This country consumes you,” he said.
Clase and Olaverria are working to apply for a visa that would allow them to stay longer. But her ability to continue in long-term care is uncertain.
Despite this, Clase carries forward, focused on the familiar paths of his daily routine, all of which lead to Olaverria.
“The majority of my time,” he said, “I dedicate it to my wife.”
___
This report is part of “Upheaval Across America,” an examination of immigration enforcement under the second Trump administration produced by Carnegie-Knight News21. For more stories, visit https://upheaval.news21.com/
Rep. Julia Letlow won Louisiana’s Republican Senate primary runoff Saturday, defeating former Rep. John Fleming.
Her win comes as a victory for President Donald Trump, who has endorsed her repeatedly throughout the race — including before she was even officially running.
Letlow made history in 2021 when she became the first Republican woman to represent Louisiana in Congress. In that special election, she won the seat that her late husband, Luke Letlow, had won prior to dying of complications related to Covid-19 in December 2020.
Letlow had no political experience prior to running for her late husband’s seat. She holds a doctorate in communication from the University of South Florida and worked as an administrator for Tulane University and the University of Louisiana, according to her LinkedIn page. Nonetheless, she won the special election House race with nearly 65% of the vote.
In Congress, she has served on the appropriations and education committees, and has been a reliably MAGA Republican.
Letlow’s win also comes as a rebuke to Fleming, who loaned himself more than $11 million, according to the Federal Election Commission, and tried running for the same seat in 2016 only to finish in fifth place in the nonpartisan primary. (Letlow did not loan her campaign any money, and took in more than $5.35 million compared to Fleming’s more than $12.1 million, FEC filings show.)
Trump has played a key role in the race. In addition to backing Letlow early on, the president also helped tank Republican incumbent Sen. Bill Cassidy’s re-election campaign in last month’s primary, based on the senator’s record of bucking his party and voting in favor of Trump’s second impeachment. In the primaryLetlow earned nearly 45% of the vote, giving her a healthy lead over both Fleming, who received about 28% of the vote, and Cassidy, who earned nearly 25%.
Ahead of Saturday’s runoff, polling showed Letlow and Fleming in a close race, with Letlow retaining a small lead in several polls.
Letlow will now proceed to the November general election to face off against the Democratic nominee, farmer Jamie Davis, who came out on top in tonight’s Democratic primary runoff.
The state has not sent a Democrat to the Senate since 2008, when Mary Landrieu won her last term in office.
Julianne McShane is a breaking news reporter for MS NOW who also covers the politics of abortion and reproductive rights. You can send her tips from a non-work device on Signal at jmcshane.19 or follow her on X or Bluesky.
Bill Pulte, the acting director of national intelligencehas stirred fear by choosing as his chief of staff a GOP election lawyer who oversaw a poll watching program that included Jack Posobiec and other conservative conspiracy theorists. The lawyer, Christina Norton, also appears to have no experience working in the intelligence community.
“It is horrifying,” a former senior U.S. intelligence official told MS NOW Saturday. “Not only does Norton have absolutely no background, experience or expertise in national security or intelligence, but her principal qualifications appear to be loyalty to Pulte and an embrace of absurd election-interference conspiracies.”
Sen. Thom Tillis, R-N.C., who has been a vocal critic of Pulte, also raised concerns about election integrity on Sunday while taking shots at the director of national intelligence and the office itself.
“We should eliminate the DNI, and we should eliminate Pulte from the DNI until that happens,” he said on BLN, adding, “I am concerned that we’re gonna continue to cast doubt on elections in November and erode what has been a 250-year tradition of a peaceful transition of power.”
Pulte’s choice of Norton is also likely to increase concerns among Democrats that President Donald Trump intends to use the Office of the Director of National Intelligence to interfere in the midterm elections. Pulte, a loyalist with no intelligence experience, has used his current position as head of federal mortgage agencies to refer political rivals of the president for federal criminal prosecution.
Rep. Jamie Raskin, D-Md., told MS NOW on Sunday that the choice “just confirms” that the “only job qualification is absolute political loyalty and devotion to Donald Trump.” But he expressed faith in the judicial system during an appearance on “The Weekend,” noting that “right now we have federal courts across the land that are rejecting their various attempts to take over the election process. Nine different federal courts have rejected the claim that the president, by executive order, can compel the states in the union to turn over all of their voter lists to Donald Trump and to the White House.”
The New York Times first reported Norton’s appointment.
The former senior intelligence official, who requested anonymity due to concerns of retaliation, told MS NOW the choice also “signals as clearly as could be that Pulte has been put at ODNI to misuse the awesome power of the U.S. intelligence community to interfere in the upcoming midterm elections.”
Norton, reached by MS NOW by telephone, declined to comment and referred questions to an ODNI spokesperson. The spokesperson declined to comment on Norton but defended Pulte’s tenure.
“Acting Director Pulte and his team are focused on carrying out President Trump’s national security priorities while faithfully executing ODNI’s statutory mission,” the spokesperson told MS NOW. “We are leading the Intelligence Community to provide President Trump with elite, apolitical intelligence that keeps America safe.”
Sen. Bill Cassidy, R-La., appearing on CBS News’ “Face the Nation” Sunday, said his objection to Pulte is “that he used personal information to target a political enemy of the president,” a reference to New York Attorney General Letitia James.
“You should not be using the force of government to crash upon somebody just because the person in charge does not like them or finds them inconvenient. The fact that Bill did that is disqualifying for someone to be the director of national intelligence,” Cassidy said.
Rep. Jim Himes, D-Conn., the ranking Democrat on the House Intelligence Committee, said on Friday that Congress would ensure that the ODNI under Pulte will “report on legitimate foreign threats to elections, not Donald Trump’s imaginary ones.”
Himes warned that, “Trump was explicit when he appointed Bill Pulte to a job he had no qualifications for that he had elections in mind.”
Trump has said in interviews with the news media that he would like to see Pulte shrink the size of the ODNI and investigate election fraud. Pulte’s predecessor, Tulsi Gabbard, participated in investigations in Georgia and Puerto Rico to find proof of Trump’s false claims that the 2020 election was stolen.
Democrats and some former intelligence officials say they worry that Pulte may try to falsely claim that his office has found evidence that foreign governments are secretly funding Democratic candidates in the midterms.
Pulte could falsely claim foreign actors have hacked U.S. voting machines, they say, and altered vote totals in favor of Democrats during the midterms. Or Trump could instruct Pulte to be present if FBI agents seize ballots and election records in November as they did earlier this year in Fulton County, Georgia.
Sen. Mark Warner, D-Va., the ranking Democrat on the Senate Intelligence Committee, warned in a statement on Friday that Pulte should not use his position to spread Trump’s false election conspiracy theories.
“The mission of ODNI is to identify and counter foreign threats, not to import election denialism into the Intelligence Community,” Warner said. “Americans have every reason to fear that this administration is once again eroding the wall between our intelligence agencies and domestic elections.”
David Rohde is the senior national security reporter for MS NOW and a two-time winner of the Pulitzer Prize for International Reporting. Previously he was the senior executive editor for national security and law for NBC News.
Having lived with Donald Trump’s infamous and baseless insult against them — “they’re eating the dogs … they’re eating the cats” — Haitian immigrants in Springfield, Ohio, are bracing for a far bigger injury.
More than 10,000 Haitians across Ohio and hundreds of thousands more around the country who had Temporary Protected Status now face the imminent prospect of deportation. The Supreme Court ruled Thursday that the Trump administration can halt those legal protections for Haitians and Syrians and resume forcing them to leave.
Justice Samuel Alito’s opinionfor the court’s Republican-appointed majority curbed the power of courts to review government decisions to terminate protections under the TPS program.
“They side with him on everything that he says or everything that he does, which means there is no check and balance,” said Viles Dorsainvil, a Haitian TPS holder and executive director of the Haitian Support Center in Springfield, a town Trump catapulted into a maelstrom of misinformation about immigrants when he was running to retake the White House in 2024.
“The president has that freeway in front of him to do whatever he wants to do, unfortunately, and most of the time to a minority group of people,” added Dorsainvil, who has lived in the United States since 2020.
In a country rife with political and economic instability, Haitians returning from the U.S. are in danger of being killed or kidnapped, said Dorsainvil’s colleague at the Haitian Support Center, Rose Thamar Joseph.
“There is this perception in Haiti that if you are living here in the United States, you have money, so you are living your good life, so sending people back to Haiti will put them in real danger,” Joseph said.
Staying in the U.S. without legal status creates a different crisis.
“We received calls this morning from people saying that, unfortunately, starting on July 1, they won’t be able to go to work anymore,” Joseph said Friday.
Joseph predicted that families would be separated during the deportation process.
“We know that there will be separation,” she said. “A lot of those parents with TPS … they have kids who were born in the United States, so we know that it will happen, not for everybody, not for all the families, but it will happen,” she said.
The oncoming nightmare for the Haitian community in Springfield was, in many ways, predictable after Trump notoriously targeted them on the debate stage against then-Vice President Kamala Harris in the fall of 2024.
“They are eating the dogs. The people that came in, they are eating the cats. They’re eating – they are eating the pets of the people that live there,” Trump said without a shred of evidence, greatly amplifying an unfounded rumor that had been confined to smaller corners of social media.
That rhetoric continued Trump’s track record of racist languageparticularly when it comes to immigration, including during his first White House stint when he referred during his first to Haiti and other majority non-white nations as “shithole” countries.
Dorsainvil argued that the Supreme Court’s decision Thursday proved his beliefs are institutionalized, calling it “a validation of all those bad rhetorics of the president against us.”
Asked by MS NOW if those with TPS should expect to be deported, White House Deputy Chief of Staff Stephen Miller said, “Well, of course. If you no longer have status in this country, then you’re supposed to be deported.”
Miller, the architect of the administration’s immigration policy, went on to single out the Haitian population by name.
But the outcry against the court’s ruling blurs party lines in Ohio.
“Changing the immigration status of these individuals is not in the best interest of the United States nor Ohio,” Republican Gov. Mike DeWine said.
Springfield’s Republican mayorRob Rue, has denounced Trump’s misinformation about his community as dangerous from the start.
“Many of the individuals affected by this decision are our neighbors, coworkers, business owners, taxpayers, and parents,” Rue said in a statement after the ruling came down. “They contribute to our local economy, support our schools, strengthen our neighborhoods, and have become part of the fabric of Springfield.”
Alex Tabet is a reporter for MS NOW.
- Capitol agenda: House GOP agenda gets tenuous Trump lifeline
- Iranian diplomat blasts ‘pseudo-VAR’ interventions after World Cup exit
- Rep. Julia Letlow wins Louisiana GOP Senate primary runoff
- ‘Horrifying’: Pulte’s choice for top spy aide stokes fears of Trump vote tampering
- In Springfield, Ohio, Trump’s rhetoric becomes a grim reality
- Jeffries congratulates NYC democratic socialists on their House primary wins
- Iranian drones attack Bahrain and a ship is struck in the strait after U.S. airstrikes
- World Cup attendance: The potential 2028ers
- ‘Héros canadiens’: Carney cheers Canada’s late win
- AI regulation group is biggest spender on World Cup TV ads
-
Politics1 year agoFormer ‘Squad’ members launching ‘Bowman and Bush’ YouTube show
-
The Dictatorship1 year agoLuigi Mangione acknowledges public support in first official statement since arrest
-
Politics1 year agoFormer Kentucky AG Daniel Cameron launches Senate bid
-
Uncategorized2 years ago
Bob Good to step down as Freedom Caucus chair this week
-
The Josh Fourrier Show2 years agoDOOMSDAY: Trump won, now what?
-
The Dictatorship1 year agoPete Hegseth’s tenure at the Pentagon goes from bad to worse
-
Politics1 year agoBlue Light News’s Editorial Director Ryan Hutchins speaks at Blue Light News’s 2025 Governors Summit
-
The Dictatorship10 months agoMike Johnson sums up the GOP’s arrogant position on military occupation with two words