The Dictatorship
What sets Bill Burr apart from the comedic manosphere
Bill Burr talks a whole lot about men in his new comedy special “Drop Dead Years,” which debuted on Hulu on Friday. Why is it, he wonders aloud, that only men “drop dead,” usually between the ages of 49 and 61, sometimes while manscaping “in the upstairs bathroom while listening to AC/DC”? How come “men aren’t allowed to be sad”? “We’re allowed,” he continues, “to be one of two things: mad or ‘fine.’ That’s it.” If you want to see sad men doing sad things in their natural sad habitat, Burr suggests, visit your local Guitar Center.
Burr is also thinking about men in much more personal terms. “Drop Dead Years” opens up with the comedian, offstage, reflecting candidly:
It’s kind of a weird thing to be over 50 and realize how f—-d up you are. Like, I thought I did stand-up because I loved comedy. And then what I really figured out is that, no, that’s not why I did it. I did stand-up because that was the easiest way to walk into a room full of a bunch of people that I didn’t know and make everybody like me. All of the way I’ve moved through the world has always been like, ‘Where’s the place I have the least chance of being hurt?’
Bill Burr is a therapeutic work in progress. He’s bravely figuring himself out … in public. The process, however, is not free of contradictions. Nor is it going very smoothly.
In “Drop Dead Years,” as in previous specials, he copiously mocks women, feminists, gays, liberalstrans people, overweight people, etc. And while the results are often very funny, this sure is an odd way to get “everybody” in the room to like him.
The response to his controversial “Saturday Night Live” monologue of 2020in which he lit up “cancel culture,” is a case in point. As is his postelection 2024 “SNL” appearancewhen he counseled women not to wear pantsuits like Kamala Harris did. Instead, the ladies who seek elected office should “whore it up a bit.”
What truly separates Burr from the manosphere bros is that he appears to be making an earnest attempt at introspection.
It’s tempting to situate a comedian like Burr in the present comedic “manosphere.” That would be the dank man cave where Joe RoganTony HinchcliffeTheo Von and others trash liberal pieties, garner immense crowds and earn success and influence in the process. Like them, Burr’s got the stage rage. He’s got the confrontational “I’m so mad my heart is about to explode!” affect. He too delights in (rhetorically) coldcocking minorities.
But Burr is different. He’s not only older than these boys, he is infinitely more intelligent. A heady gag in “Drop Dead Years” about KKK members riding in the HOV lane reminds us that Burr is a thinking man’s comic in the style of George Carlin. He’s also an exceptionally skilled physical actor. He uses his body, pasty white face and bald dome (which shines like a diamond under the stage lights) in ways that few can rival: I especially appreciated his imitation of a man dropping dead out of a golf cart.
And then there’s what we might call Burr’s balance. He’s not averse to punching up. In an interview with NPR’s Terry Gross this past week, the comic set his sights on Elon Musk. “I just refuse to believe,” Burr declared, reflecting on the billionaire’s Inauguration Day salutes“that it was an accidental, two-time ‘Sieg heil.’”
Yet what truly separates Burr from the manosphere bros is that he appears to be making an earnest attempt at introspection. As the opening comments in this latest special suggest, Burr is doing the work, limning the pain, trying to be a better husband and dad. He’s boldly marching into the aforementioned room — a “room,” I might add, that streams to a few million people — and bleeding out.
Burr’s asking questions. Why can’t men wrap themselves in an afghan, sit in a corner and brood like women can? Why can’t men be sad? The problem is that, like Dave Chappellehe also demands to know why he can’t use a homophobic slur anymore.
His public therapeutic turn, with all of its contradictions, is equally evident in the NPR interview with Gross. One second he’s decimating Musk’s “laminated face” and the next (like, literally one second later), he’s talking about why he hates liberals. One second he’s confronting his flawed masculinity; moments later, he’s subjecting Gross to the type of off-the-shelf manosphere rebuttals that are guaranteed to drive liberal women, among others, to distraction. (The normally serene Gross, for her part, at some points low-key loses her patience with Burr’s evasions and interruptions.)
Burr is doing the work, limning the pain, trying to be a better husband and dad.
Bill Burr is extremely funny. But politically, the man is completely incomprehensible.
In terms of psychic self-awareness, I don’t think he’s quite “there” yet (wherever that may be). Admirably, he’s realized that he performs his comedy to avoid getting hurt. It therefore boggles the mind that he seems to make no effort to interrogate whether and how his jokes, broadcast to multitudes, might hurt other people, whether that’s gay men, or women bemoaning Harris’ election loss (and their personal freedoms).
The closing sequence of “Drop Dead Years” provides a clue as to how Burr may presently resolve all this psychic tumult. A few moments earlier, he had mentioned that he was touched inappropriately as a child (“I got touched as a kid”). Now the credits have rolled, we’re in the alley behind the theater. Away from the crowd. Everything’s quiet. Burr is sitting on the stoop of the stage door. His buddy is eating a sandwich and drinking a beer. Burr is smoking a cigar. It’s a good cigar. Maybe, the moment suggests, men achieve psychic resolution by being alone with other men.
Jacques Berlinerblauis a professor of Jewish civilization at Georgetown University. He has authored numerous books about the subject of secularism, including the recent “Secularism: The Basics” (Routledge). He has also written about American higher education in “Campus Confidential: How College Works, and Doesn’t, For Professors, Parents and Students” (Melville House). With Professor Terrence Johnson, he is a co-author of “Blacks and Jews in America: An Invitation to Dialogue” (Georgetown). His current research concentrates on the nexus between literature and comedy on the one side and cultural conflicts on the other.
The Dictatorship
Wednesday’s Mini-Report, 5.13.26
Today’s edition of quick hits.
* Warsh was confirmed with 54 votes: “The Senate voted to install Kevin Warsh as chair of the Federal Reserve on Wednesday, handing the millionaire Trump ally the reins of America’s monetary policy even as he faced skepticism over his ability to remain independent of presidential influence.”
* When Barack Obama visited China in 2009, he was greeted by Xi Jinping himself. Nearly two decades later: “President Trump arrived Wednesday night in Beijing, where he was welcomed by a military band, an honor guard, hundreds of Chinese youth waving flags and China’s vice president, Han Zheng. Such carefully designed receptions for foreign leaders telegraph Beijing’s attitude toward these visits. … This time, they sent someone who is high-level but whose position is mostly that of a figurehead — which could be a way to send a layered message.”
* All the news on inflation is bad: “Wholesale prices in April posted their highest annual increase in more than three years, signaling more nettlesome inflation as pipeline costs intensify. The producer price index rose a seasonally adjusted 1.4% for the month, much higher than the 0.5% Dow Jones consensus forecast and the upwardly revised 0.7% March increase, the Bureau of Labor Statistics reported Wednesday. This was the largest monthly gain since March 2022.”
* The bar is low, but this represents a little progress: “Republican divisions over the Iran war deepened on Wednesday as three GOP senators voted with Democrats to curtail the conflict, signaling greater headwinds for President Donald Trump as he seeks to stem economic impacts that have damaged the party’s political standing. While the Democratic-led measure failed, it was the closest a war powers vote came to advancing in the Senate in the seven attempts since the war began as GOP concerns slowly grow over the path forward.”
* ICE’s newest chief: “The Department of Homeland Security has selected David Venturella, a former private prison executive, to lead U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, the agency at the center of President Donald Trump’s controversial effort to detain and deport millions of undocumented immigrants. Venturella, who has served as a senior ICE adviser since February 2025, will be named acting director following the departure of Todd M. Lyons, DHS spokeswoman Lauren Bis said in a statement Tuesday.”
* In related news: “Ten thousand losses. That’s the Trump administration’s track record in court as federal judges grapple with the way ICE agents have swept through major U.S. cities and detained thousands of people in support of President Donald Trump’s aggressive deportation agenda.”
* It’s always interesting to me when discharge petitions work: “A bipartisan effort to force a vote on legislation sending fresh American security aid to Ukraine has amassed the 218 signatures needed to force a floor vote, the latest in a series of instances of rank-and-file lawmakers wresting control of the chamber’s agenda from Republican leaders.”
See you tomorrow.
Steve Benen is a producer for “The Rachel Maddow Show,” the editor of MaddowBlog and an MS NOW political contributor. He’s also the bestselling author of “Ministry of Truth: Democracy, Reality, and the Republicans’ War on the Recent Past.”
The Dictatorship
The MAGA movement’s KKK revisionism is revealing
Ku Klux Klan denialism is in vogue for the MAGA movement these days.
As the GOP uses Jim Crow-like racial profiling and voter suppression tactics such as gerrymanderingsome Republicans are engaged in a campaign of obfuscation and misinformation to downplay allegations of racism.
And it increasingly seems that some of President Donald Trump’s supporters want to use falsehoods about the KKK to advance their goals.
Last week’s fact-free diatribe from Rep. Harriet Hageman, R-Wyo., about the KKK supposedly being a leftist organization is a prime example. As I recently wroteRepublicans have used the Justice Department’s dubious indictment of the anti-racist Southern Poverty Law Center to falsely portray racist extremism, which the SPLC tracks and investigates, as either nonexistent or a liberal contrivance. This tactic mirrors rhetoric deployed by conservatives who sought to deny the threat of the KKK during its rise, or even its mere existence.
The aforementioned falsehoods about the SPLC were the subject of an exchange Hageman had with conservative podcaster Winston Marshall in which she made the demonstrably false claim that the KKK, Nazis and the Aryan Nation are “far-left organizations” and “always have been.”
Hageman told Marshall:
The Aryan Nation, the Nazis and the KKK are not far-right organizations. Those are far-left organizations, and they always have been. The KKK was created and started by the Democrats in the United States to prevent Blacks from being able to participate in the political arena, if you will. So I’m going to say they’ve never been associated with the right; they’ve always been associated with the left.
This is the kind of derangement that would make a reputable historian weep.
And you can see in Hageman’s comments why speaking of politics in directional terms (i.e., “right” vs. “left”) is flawed. The KKK has never been liberal and essentially has always been a conservative group of Christian white supremacists. Some Republicans — particularly Black supporters of Trump’s, as we have seen lately — like to portray Democrats as the party of the KKK because at the time of the organization’s rise, the white Christian conservatives most vehemently opposed to Black civil rights called themselves Democrats.
But in reality, the KKK didn’t belong to any particular party, and the Democratic Party didn’t create it. People suggesting otherwise are most likely trying to score cheap political points.
As historian Elaine Frantz explained in a 2011 essay titled “Klan Skepticism and Denial in Reconstruction-Era Public Discourse,” the conspiracy to turn a blind eye to the KKK and its racist terrorism was a bipartisan project:
While Klansmen and their Democratic political allies deliberately spread doubt about Klan reports, they could not have succeeded as thoroughly as they did without the substantial, if intermittent, collaboration of their Republican opponents.
Hageman and some of her fellow Trump supporters apparently don’t want Republicans to be associated with racists, but pseudointellectual diatribes on American history are not the way to avoid that. Instead, I’d suggest not using phrases popularized by the KKK decades ago, such as “America First,” and refraining from celebrating former klan leaders, like Nathan Bedford Forrest.
And, of course, ceasing the GOP’s demonstrable and devastating political crusade against Black people would go a long way.
Ja’han Jones is an MS NOW opinion blogger. He previously wrote The ReidOut Blog.
The Dictatorship
Raskin wants answers from Todd Blanche about alleged payments to fired FBI agents
The Trump administration allegedly paid off FBI agents fired or punished for misconduct, including one who impeded a probe into a white nationalist group and another agent who appeared at the Capitol during the Jan. 6 insurrection.
Those are the bombshell claims at the heart of a new probe Maryland Democratic Rep. Jamie Raskin opened Tuesday into the Justice Department, Acting Attorney General Todd Blanche and FBI Director Kash Patel.
Raskin “launched an investigation into a scheme inside the Department of Justice (DOJ) to direct millions of taxpayer dollars to FBI agents fired for serious misconduct, many of whom are aligned with Donald Trump,” according to a press release announcing the probe.
Raskin’s letter to Blanche demands details on the alleged payouts, which Raskin said were negotiated by Empower Oversight, a well-funded conservative activist group linked to Iowa Sen. Chuck Grassley that has focused on MAGA conspiracy theories under the guise of defending “whistleblowers.”
Raskin cites as an example an FBI agent who allegedly received a payout and reinstatement at the FBI after being removed for refusing to participate in a probe of the white supremacist group Patriot Front, which has been involved in acts of violence and intimidation toward Black people and immigrants. Raskin said this occurred despite revelations that the agent also “engaged in commercial sex overseas while on an official FBI assignment—unequivocal grounds for security clearance revocation and dismissal from the FBI.” The letter notes the agent was reinstated under Patel.
This claim seems particularly noteworthy in light of the Trump Justice Department’s indictment of the Southern Poverty Law Centerwhich investigates racist extremism and has even previously assisted the DOJ in such investigations. The SPLC is seemingly being targeted for purported fraud in connection with its work against white supremacist groups. Meanwhile, Raskin’s allegation is that the Justice Department rewarded someone for refusing to investigate white supremacy.
Raskin’s list of alleged payouts overseen by Blanche or Patel includes an agent who was reinstated and given more than $100,000 by the department after a court declined to reinstate him after he leaked details of a probe into the far-right group Project Veritas to the media. The representative also references an agent who was reinstated and given his security clearance back after facing punishment over documents, including photos and video, that showed him in a restricted area during the Jan. 6 insurrection at the U.S. Capitol back in 2021.
“There are many more examples of these indefensible and lawless payments,” Raskin’s letter to Blanche claims.
The letter demands a list of all FBI or DOJ employees who have received settlements or back pay after being fired or disciplined for alleged misconduct, and all documents pertaining to the negotiations.
Raskin lays out the picture of a lawless regime that prioritizes loyalty to the president — the first to be convicted of a felony — and subservience to his political agenda over seemingly all else. If the allegations are accurate, it’s a disturbing development, but arguably a predictable one.
The DOJ did not immediately respond to MS NOW’s request for comment.
Ja’han Jones is an MS NOW opinion blogger. He previously wrote The ReidOut Blog.
-
Politics1 year agoFormer ‘Squad’ members launching ‘Bowman and Bush’ YouTube show
-
The Dictatorship1 year agoLuigi Mangione acknowledges public support in first official statement since arrest
-
Politics1 year agoFormer Kentucky AG Daniel Cameron launches Senate bid
-
Uncategorized1 year ago
Bob Good to step down as Freedom Caucus chair this week
-
The Dictatorship1 year agoPete Hegseth’s tenure at the Pentagon goes from bad to worse
-
Politics1 year agoBlue Light News’s Editorial Director Ryan Hutchins speaks at Blue Light News’s 2025 Governors Summit
-
The Dictatorship8 months agoMike Johnson sums up the GOP’s arrogant position on military occupation with two words
-
The Josh Fourrier Show2 years agoDOOMSDAY: Trump won, now what?








