The Dictatorship
RFK Jr. says he’s making the CDC more ‘trustworthy.’ These states know better.
On Wednesday, California, Oregon and Washington announced a new collaborative alliance that officials say “will help safeguard scientific expertise by ensuring that public health policies in California, Oregon, and Washington are informed by trusted scientists, clinicians, and other public health leaders.” For starters, the alliance will work toward immunization guidelines “informed by respected national medical organizations.” Then, on Thursday, Hawaii announced that it’s also joining the alliance.
Nine former CDC directors used language including “alarming,” “a raging fire” and “hurting badly” to describe the state of things at the CDC.
Immunization guidelines would normally be issued by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, but in a shockingly short period of time, Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. has devastated its critical public health functions. In a New York Times op-ed this weeknine former CDC directors used language including “alarming,” “a raging fire” and “hurting badly” to describe the state of things at the CDC.
They decried the developments at the CDC that include Kennedy’s firing thousands of federal health workers and well-qualified leaders (among them the CDC director, Susan Monarez), dismantling key public health programs, promoting unproven treatments, failing to encourage vaccination during a major measles outbreak, promoting flawed science and inaccurate health statements to disparage vaccines, canceling investments in medical research and supporting legislation that will lead to the loss of health coverage for millions of Americans.
Kennedy also replaced seasoned experts on federal health advisory committees, including members of the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices, with people whose relevant qualifications seem to be that they share his views.
In a contentious hearing before the Senate Finance Committee on Thursday during which Kennedy was grilled by Republicans and Democrats for his management of HHS, he insisted his actions were geared toward making the CDC “trustworthy.” However, Sen. Ron Wyden of Oregon, the ranking Democrat on the committee, said, “Every single day, there’s been an action that endangers the health and wellness of American families.” He said, “Robert Kennedy has elevated conspiracy theorists, crackpots and grifters to make life-or-death decisions about the health care of the American people.”
In their New York Times op-ed, the former CDC directors exhorted the nation to rally to protect the health of every American. Forming the West Coast Health Alliance appears to be how the four states mentioned are rallying on behalf of the American people. While the details have yet to emerge, its intent is clear: restore science, in whatever way and at whatever scale we can.
It’s surreal that medical professionals and the American public can no longer depend on the CDC. For decades, the CDC has led public health campaigns, defined priority areas for boosting national health, issued recommendations for preventive measures that guided clinicians and communities and defined what insurers will cover. Relying on the leadership of this agency has long been embedded in the practice of health care and public health. Before Kennedy helped crumble it, the CDC’s bedrock was made up of qualified, credible scientists leading rigorous processes, working under an unwavering mission to preserve the safety and the health of the nation.
Unfortunately, Florida is following the CDC’s lead, abandoning school vaccination mandates that have protected the public from diseases such as measles and whooping cough. Even in normal times, doctors’ offices and emergency rooms face challenges meeting the October-to-March surges in RSV, influenza and Covid. Now relying on the CDC — or the empty hull that carries its name — will put our patients at a disadvantage.
No one wakes up and decides to recreate the functions of the CDC to make a statement
To quote the supercomputer in the 1980s apocalyptic movie “War Games,” “The only winning move is not to play.”
And so my state of Oregon, along with Washington, California and Hawaii, wisely decided to step away from a dysfunctional enterprise and establish its own evidence-based health alliance.
No one wakes up and decides to re-create the functions of the CDC to make a statement. This will be a monumental task for states that are fighting a million battles to preserve the health of their residents. The slashing of Medicaid funding alone is a catastrophe that is already requiring an outpouring of ingenuity from states’ public health agencies.
But the establishment of this alliance is a functional necessity. The practice of medicine in ordinary times is tenable because we have working guidelines for preventing illness and treating patients for common conditions. This involves prevention of harmful infectious diseases through immunization, yes, but also preventing violence, opioid overdose, heart disease, lead poisoning and the myriad other health threats we face. We have relied on the CDC for the topical and methodologic expertise that allowed it to synthesize vast amounts of evidence into national recommendations.
Maybe it will again one day.
Until then, our reaction to science’s being dismantled in plain sight must be to use creative solutions to build it back up. There is a role for our medical societies to advocate for scientifically grounded practices for the populations they represent. There is a role for private philanthropy’s stepping in to keep research funded. There is a role for insurance companies to look for solid evidence from reliable sources to guide their coverage decisions so costs do not skyrocket for individuals as health care providers continue to try to provide routine care.
And there is a huge role for our states’ leaders and their health agencies, which are chronically overburdened and underfunded but staffed by those who believe in the fundamental charge of public health: to protect and improve the health of the entire population.
In a devastating time for public health, at least these four states are showing us that some parts of government are still investing in keeping us all alive and well.
Esther Choo, M.D. M.P.H., is an emergency medicine physician, health policy researcher and founding member of Equity Quotient, a company that advises organizations on building cultures of equity. She has provided commentary on the pandemic and other health care topics through appearances on BLN, BLN, the BBC and Yahoo! Finance and editorials published in The Lancet, the British Medical Journal, The Washington Post, NBC Think and USA Today.
The Dictatorship
Stephanie Ruhle rips Trump official for downplaying war’s economic impact
MS NOW’s Stephanie Ruhle set the facts straight on Tuesday’s “The 11th Hour,” after Donald Trump’s National Economic Council Director Kevin Hassett tried to downplay the effect the Iran war is having on American consumers.
During an interview with CNBCHassett said the U.S. economy was “fundamentally sound” and that if the war continued, it “wouldn’t really disrupt the U.S. economy very much at all.” While he acknowledged that a prolonged conflict would “hurt consumers,” he said that was “the last of our concerns right now.”
“We are now in the third week of the war,” Ruhle said after playing a clip of the Trump official’s comments. “Kevin Hassett says the war would not disrupt the economy very much at all. But for facts’ sake, it already has.”
“Everybody from Wall Street to Main Street is trying to navigate the growing economic risks created by the war with Iran,” she said, noting that while markets finished strong on Tuesday, the price of oil was still climbing.
“If you have been watching this show, then you already know what it means for your wallet. Higher oil prices translate to higher prices for gas, diesel and even jet fuel, all the things that keep our economy — not just our economy, but the global economy — humming along,” she explained.
If Trump officials want to understand the reality many Americans are facing, the MS NOW host advised them simply to “walk outside.”
“Look at gas prices,” she said. “We have had farmer after farmer on this network warning what increased diesel prices do for their tractors, what increased fertilizer prices do. And not to mention, there’s loads of businesses that have nothing to do with the Strait of Hormuz, but they’re in this moment where they’re like, ‘I’m not hiring, I’m not growing. We’re at war. I don’t know what’s ahead.’”
While Ruhle assured viewers that the U.S. economy is “resilient,” she said the war comes as many Americans are already struggling with inflation due to Trump’s tariffs. “When you have this kind of stress, even strong economies can start to buckle,” she warned.
You can watch Ruhle’s full analysis in the clip at the top of the page.
Allison Detzel is an editor/producer for MS NOW. She was previously a segment producer for “AYMAN” and “The Mehdi Hasan Show.”
The Dictatorship
The Tea, Spilled by Morning Joe: ‘The SAVE Act is horrible legislation’
This is the March 18, 2026, edition of “The Tea, Spilled by Morning Joe” newsletter.Subscribe hereto get it delivered straight to your inbox Monday through Friday.
QUOTE OF THE DAY
“Trump promised to get the U.S. out of ‘stupid wars.’ But now he and John Bolton are on the brink of launching us into a very stupid and costly war with Iran.”
— Tulsi Gabbard, the current director of national intelligence, while running for president as a Democrat in 2019
JOE’S NOTE
David Drucker, writer for The Dispatch and an opinion columnist for Bloomberg News, joined us today to break down the voter dynamics among registered Democratic voters amid the results from Tuesday’s elections in Illinois.
JS: David, what did last night’s election results in Illinois say about the strength of moderate candidates in the Democratic Party?
DD: Well, a Democratic poll for Third Way, a centrist think tank, found that the typical Democratic primary voter is a white woman over 55 without a college degree. Most Democratic primary voters end up being white, female, older, and not college-educated.
JS: What was your takeaway?
DD: It confirms a familiar pattern. In both parties, the most pragmatic presidential candidate usually wins the nomination. Voters may like passion, but when it’s time to choose, they go with electability.
The poll also showed voters want a fighter willing to take on Republicans, but their own views aren’t far left.
JS: After rarely discussing faith on the campaign trail for years, Democrats seem more comfortable doing so now. Is this why?
DD: One surprise to me was that 57% of Democratic primary voters identify as Christian, many as evangelical or born-again. It’s a reminder that most Democratic voters resemble mainstream America. If you want to win in 2028, you need to appeal to that middle, not just the progressive fringe.
JS: I noticed the same divide during the 2020 Democratic debates — candidates focused on Twitter instead of voters. [Joe] Biden was the lone moderate, and he swept the primaries after South Carolina.
MB: Why do you think that happened when the energy seemed to be with other Democratic candidates?
JS: Younger voters are more left-leaning. But for now, the average Democrat is a 55-year-old white woman who makes up a centrist coalition with voters of color who tend to be moderate, especially Black women and many Hispanic voters. Despite the online noise, Democrats still win from the middle.
Elisabeth Bumiller: Exactly. Every Democratic president for decades — Biden, Obama, Clinton, Carter — has been a moderate. That could change, with younger progressives like Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez or New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani energizing the base. But for now, the center still defines the party.
It is striking, though, that the average primary voter isn’t college-educated, given Democrats’ reputation as the party of the educated class.
DD: Right. These are self-identified primary voters. The party’s base has become more college-educated overall, but this shows how the primary electorate differs. Democrats have moved somewhat left over time, but the average voter still sees themselves as center-left, pragmatic, and tolerant of disagreement. They want fighters who focus on priorities, not purity tests. Biden’s success in 2020 proves that dynamic still holds.
JS: And to be clear, no one’s saying Democrats are conservative — just that they may be less progressive as a whole than social media suggests.
CHART OF THE DAY

EYES WIDE SHUT

It happens to all of us: You snap awake in the middle of the night, the room still dark, your alarm hours away — and you just can’t get back to sleep.
About 1 in 5 Americans experiences this kind of middle-of-the-night insomnia, according to The Washington Post. If you’re one of them, a simple breathing trick may help.
Try the 4-7-8 method: Inhale for four seconds, hold for seven, then exhale slowly for eight. Repeat until your body starts to settle.
If that doesn’t work, you might try a cognitive shuffle or progressive muscle relaxation. And, of course, leave your phone alone.
ON THIS DATE

In 1990, thieves posing as police officers slipped into Boston’s Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum and made off with 13 works of art — among them paintings by Rembrandt and Vermeer — valued at more than $500 million.
More than three decades later, it remains the largest unsolved art heist in history and is the subject of the Netflix docuseries “This Is a Robbery,” directed and co-produced by the Barnicle boys!

A CONVERSATION WITH SEN. MARK KELLY
was. Sen. Mark Kelly of Arizona joined “Morning Joe” ahead of the briefing to discuss his views on the conflict — and the answers he says the American people deserve.
JS: Senator, you know what it’s like to go into combat. What’s on your mind today when you think about those serving in the U.S. military?
MK: We’ve got the most incredible men and women serving this country, and I think it’s fair to say their family members are serving as well. It’s challenging to live that life. They deserve to have a government that’s looking out for their best interests, and I’m not sure that’s the case right now.
JS: What would you tell loved ones watching the news, nervous about their sons or daughters being deployed in the Middle East?
MK: It’s challenging, because the president entered this war without a strategic goal, without a plan, without a timeline.
I tell them I’ve got their backs — I’ll keep pushing this administration to make better decisions and hold them accountable when they don’t.
JS: You’re heading today into a major intelligence briefing. What’s the key question you need answered?
MK: I want to know how these decisions are actually making Americans safer — because right now, it doesn’t look that way. The president is surrounded by people who won’t challenge him, and that’s dangerous, especially on matters of national security.
When I was in charge of the space shuttle, I used to tell my crew members that they were required to question my decisions, especially when it came to safety or mission success.
JL: There are now real questions about whether Iran was an imminent threat. How do you plan to address that today?
MK: I want clarity on what intelligence was presented to the president — and whether anyone raised concerns about the risks, including in the Strait of Hormuz.
The president doesn’t seem to fully understand the military’s capabilities or how it operates.
JS: Senator, let’s talk about the SAVE Act. People on social media keep pushing the lie that it’s the only way to save America. What’s really going on here?
MK: This goes far beyond voter ID. People would have to re-register, and many wouldn’t even be able to use a military ID. It puts real barriers in front of working people and seniors who may not have the documents required.
We’re going to do everything we can to stop this. The SAVE Act is horrible legislation that would take our country back decades.
This conversation has been condensed and edited for brevity and clarity.
EXTRA HOT TEA
1 IN 9.2 QUINTILLION
— The mathematical odds of successfully predicting an entire March Madness bracket
ONE MORE SHOT

Willie Nelson performs in concert during the 11th Annual Luck Potluck at Luck Ranch last night in Spicewood, Texas.
CATCH UP ON MORNING JOE



The Dictatorship
Top counterterrorism official Kent resigns over Trump’s Iran war, says Iran posed no imminent threat
WASHINGTON (AP) — Joe Kent, the director of the National Counterterrorism Center, announced his resignation on Tuesday, citing his concerns about the justification for military strikes in Iran and saying he “cannot in good conscience” back the Trump administration’s war.
“Iran posed no imminent threat to our nation, and it is clear that we started this war due to pressure from Israel and its powerful American lobby,” Kent said in a statement posted on social media, making claims President Donald Trump has denied.
Kent, a former Green Beret and political candidate with connections to right-wing extremistswas confirmed last July on a 52-44 vote. As head of the National Counterterrorism Center, he was in charge of an agency tasked with analyzing and detecting terrorist threats.
His resignation demonstrates that the unease about the war within Trump’s base extends to at least one senior member of his Republican administration.
The leadership change comes at a time of heightened concern about terrorism following several recent violent attacks in the U.S.
President Donald Trump pauses after signing an executive order in the Oval Office of the White House, Monday, March 16, 2026, in Washington. (AP Photo/Julia Demaree Nikhinson)
President Donald Trump pauses after signing an executive order in the Oval Office of the White House, Monday, March 16, 2026, in Washington. (AP Photo/Julia Demaree Nikhinson)
Justification for Iran strikes at heart of resignation
AP AUDIO: Top counterterrorism official Kent resigns over Trump’s Iran war, says Iran posed no imminent threat
AP Washington correspondent Sagar Meghani reports on the National Counterterrorism Center’s director resigning over the Iran war.
Kent’s decision came down to the reasoning behind the strikes on Iran, he wrote in his resignation letter.
Trump has offered shifting reasons for the strikes and has pushed back on claims that Israel forced the U.S. to act. House Speaker Mike Johnson has suggested the White House believed Israel was determined to strike on its own, leaving the Republican president with a “very difficult decision.”
Speaking with reporters in the Oval Office on Tuesday, Trump said he always thought Kent was “weak on security” and if someone in his administration did not believe Iran was a threat, “we don’t want those people.”
“They’re not smart people, or they’re not savvy people,” Trump said. “Iran was a tremendous threat.”
A year ago, in nominating Kent, Trump praised him as a man who had “hunted down terrorists and criminals his entire adult life.”
Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard, whose office oversaw Kent’s work, wrote in a social media post Tuesday that it was up to Trump to decide whether Iran posed a threat.
“After carefully reviewing all the information before him, President Trump concluded that the terrorist Islamist regime in Iran posed an imminent threat and he took action based on that conclusion,” Gabbard wrote in the post. She did not mention her own views of the strikes.
Democrats strongly opposed Kent’s confirmation because of his past ties to far-right figures and conspiracy theories. But following his resignation, Sen. Mark Warner of Virginia, the top Democrat on the Senate Intelligence Committee, said Kent’s concerns about the war in Iran were justified.
“I strongly disagree with many of the positions he has espoused over the years, particularly those that risk politicizing our intelligence community,” Warner said. “But on this point, he is right: There was no credible evidence of an imminent threat from Iran that would justify rushing the United States into another war of choice in the Middle East.”
Johnson, though, pushed back on Kent’s claims at a press conference on Tuesday.
“I got all the briefings. We all understood that there was clearly an imminent threat that Iran was very close to the enrichment of nuclear capability and they were building missiles at a pace no one in the region could keep up with,” Johnson said.
Johnson said he is convinced that if Trump had waited “we would have mass casualties of Americans, service members and others, and our installation would have been dramatically damaged.”
Departure follows three recent acts of violence
In New York City, two men who federal authorities say were inspired by the Islamic State group took powerful homemade bombs to a far-right protest outside the mayoral mansion.
In Michigan, a naturalized citizen from Lebanon rammed his vehicle into a synagogue, where he was shot at by security before he fatally shot himself.
And in Virginia, a man previously imprisoned on a terrorism conviction opened fire in a university classroom. Officials said the attack ended when he was killed by students.
Gabbard, CIA Director John Ratcliffe and FBI Director Kash Patel are scheduled to testify before lawmakers this week about threats facing the U.S., an annual hearing likely to be dominated this year by questions about the Iran war and the revelation that outdated intelligence likely led to the U.S. firing a missile that hit an elementary school in Iran and killed more than 165 people.
A veteran and former congresswoman from Hawaii, Gabbard has previously criticized talk of military strikes in Iran. Six years ago she said that “an all out war with Iran would make the wars that we’ve seen in Iraq and Afghanistan look like a picnic. It will be far more costly in lives, American lives, and American taxpayer dollars — and all towards accomplishing what goal? What objective?”
A spokesperson for Gabbard declined to answer questions about Gabbard’s views on the current strikes.
A popular figure among Trump supporters
Kent’s military background and his personal story of sacrifice made him a compelling figure among Trump supporters.
Before joining Trump’s administration, Kent ran two unsuccessful campaigns for Congress in Washington state. As a Green Beret, he saw combat in 11 deployments before retiring to join the CIA. He also endured tragedy: His wife, a Navy cryptologist, was killed by a suicide bomber in 2019 in Syria, leaving him with two young sons. Kent, 45, has since remarried.
During the United States’ chaotic withdrawal from Afghanistan in 2021, Kent criticized what he said was a misguided desire for nation building by some in Washington, D.C.
“It speaks to our hubris,” Kent told reporters while campaigning for Congress. “For us not to have learned from all this just shows that there are people making money and making their careers at the other end of it. They’ve been doing it on the backs and dead bodies of U.S. soldiers.”
During his 2022 congressional campaign, Kent paid Graham Jorgensen, a member of the far-right military group the Proud Boys, for consulting work. He also worked closely with Joey Gibson, the founder of the Christian nationalist group Patriot Prayer, and attracted support from a variety of far-right figures.
Early during his first campaign, Kent acknowledged that a political consultant set up a call intended to broaden his social media reach that was joined by Nick Fuentes, a popular right-wing influencer who has said that Jews are holding the U.S. “hostage” and once proclaimed that “Hitler was awesome, Hitler was right.”
Kent later disavowed those ties and stated that he rejected all “racism and bigotry.”
During his Senate confirmation hearing, Kent refused to distance himself from a conspiracy theory that federal agents instigated the Jan. 6, 2021, attack at the Capitol, as well as false claims that Trump won the 2020 election over Democrat Joe Biden.
Republicans praised Kent’s counterterrorism qualifications, pointing to his military and intelligence experience.
Sen. Tom Cotton, the GOP chair of the Intelligence Committee, said in a floor speech that Kent had “dedicated his career to fighting terrorism and keeping Americans safe.”
___
Associated Press writers Kevin Freking and Brian Slodysko contributed to this report.
-
The Dictatorship1 year agoLuigi Mangione acknowledges public support in first official statement since arrest
-
Politics1 year agoFormer ‘Squad’ members launching ‘Bowman and Bush’ YouTube show
-
Politics1 year agoBlue Light News’s Editorial Director Ryan Hutchins speaks at Blue Light News’s 2025 Governors Summit
-
Politics1 year agoFormer Kentucky AG Daniel Cameron launches Senate bid
-
The Dictatorship6 months agoMike Johnson sums up the GOP’s arrogant position on military occupation with two words
-
The Dictatorship1 year agoPete Hegseth’s tenure at the Pentagon goes from bad to worse
-
Politics11 months agoDemocrat challenging Joni Ernst: I want to ‘tear down’ party, ‘build it back up’
-
Uncategorized1 year ago
Bob Good to step down as Freedom Caucus chair this week




