The Dictatorship
How much should Americans fear the man who just toppled Bashar al-Assad
For 83 years, Dec. 7 has been remembered as a day of infamy. After this weekend, that day will have a new legacy — a day of freedom, as one of the most brutal and repressive regimes in modern history disappeared.
The liberation of Syria from the clutches of President Bashar al-Assadafter his family ruled the country for 50 years, is an unqualified good. How did it happen so quickly and so unexpectedly? And what comes next? I reached out to the New Yorker’s Anand Gopalwho has reported extensively from Syria over the past several yearsto help make sense of the extraordinary events of the past two weeks.
According to Gopal, three external factors loomed large. Under Assad, Syria’s biggest regional benefactor was Iran, but since the Oct. 7 attacks, it has withstood Israeli military strikes and watched its Palestinian ally, Hamas, also weakened by Israel.
Iran’s proxy, Hezbollah, had also been an important provider of military resources and fighting men for Assad — but the Islamic group has been severely diminished after weeks of Israeli attacks in Lebanon.
Finally, and perhaps most decisively, with Russia bogged down in Ukraine, Assad could no longer rely on Moscow’s direct military engagement in fighting the rebels, particularly Russia’s close air support that had become crucial for Syria’s army.
Perhaps the most striking thing about HTS, under Jolani’s leadership, is the group’s outreach to the international community.
However, perhaps the most critical factor was internal: the slow-motion decay of the Assad regime. Massive corruption, economic stagnation and the utter dysfunction of the government hollowed out the country and tested the loyalty of the military rank and file. When the rebels finally mobilized from their area of control and captured Aleppo, the country’s second largest city, on Nov. 29, the low morale of Syria’s army, combined with the lack of Russian air support, doomed Assad’s regime. Rather than fight for the country’s leader, government forces abandoned their posts — and, in some cases, also their uniforms and equipment.
Ironically, all this was happening at the same time there’d been a steady and slow move toward regional normalization. Just weeks ago, Assad attended a meeting of the Arab League in Saudi Arabia, a year after his Arab opponents had given back Syria’s seat in the organization.
Now he’s in Moscow, likely forever.
What comes next? Since the outbreak of civil war in 2011 — and even after Assad largely put down the rebel uprising — Syria has devolved into sectarian conflict.
Even before Assad’s fall, a host of rebel factions controlled much of the state’s territory, including the Syrian National Army, which is basically a Turkish proxy; the Syrian Democratic Forces, an American proxy consisting of Kurdish and Arab elements that controls around 30% of Syria’s territory; and now Hayat Tahrir al-Sham (HTS), the group responsible for the final nail in the coffin of the Assad regime. How these groups interact and cooperate (or don’t) will be crucial to Syria’s future.
Much has been made of the fact that HTS grew out of Al Qaeda’s Syria offshoot and that the United States has designated its leader, Abu Muhammad al-Jolani, a terrorist. But Jolani has gone out of his way to disown Al Qaeda, purge HTS of more extremist elements and publicly moderate his views.
Gopal, the New Yorker’s reporter, believes the ideological shift is “genuine,” and Jolani appears to be “very pragmatically minded.” Indeed, Jolani seems to be saying all the right things in the run-up to Assad’s fall and after the president’s flight to Moscow.
He’s beseeched his supporters to avoid reprisals against Assad loyalists and has consistently preached a message of unity, dignity, and justice. He’s even extended an olive branch to Syria’s Christian, Kurdish and Alawite minorities. The latter is most notable because, through the Assads, it was the Alawites that ruled Syria with an iron fist for the past five decades.
Jolani has played things well so far, but the real work begins now.
Gopal, who has watched HTS’s growth over the past several years, is less surprised by the group’s political and diplomatic success than its military capacity, which seemed to catch much of the world off guard as well. “They’ve thought about the politics of this in ways that are impressive,” he said. Indeed, after HTS’s takeover of Aleppo, Syria’s second-largest city, in late November, the group immediately moved to establish security, protect civilians and provide basic services to the city’s residents. According to Middle East analyst Aaron Zelin, this is consistent with HTS’s rule in the parts of Syria they controlled before the events of the last few weeks. These governing efforts and outreach to civilians contrasts with the Islamic State, which seemed more interested in ideological purity than institution building.
Perhaps the most striking thing about HTS, under Jolani’s leadership, is the group’s outreach to the international community. “They are very serious about wanting rapprochement with the West and refashioning themselves as a national movement, not a transnational jihadist movement,” Gopal said.
He noted that, usually, the prime audience for a rebel group is their domestic constituencies, but “HTS is different,” he said, adding, “They are attuned to the international community — and see it as a very important audience.” HTS has been in direct contact with Iran’s government and agreed to requests from Tehran to protect the country’s embassy and Shiite religious shrines. In addition, HTS has avoided antagonizing Russiaeven going so far as to leave the country’s naval bases in Syria untouched. Jolani seems to recognize that he cannot afford to alienate the various external groups who have been meddling in Syria’s affairs during its bloody civil war — even those who have caused so much needless death and destruction.
Whether Jolani and HTS stay on a moderate course remains to be seen. The potential for further sectarian conflict or score-settling is high. Moreover, there is always the possibility that Jolani is talking a good game but will change his stripes once HTS achieves power. Even in an ideal world, consolidating their rule, forming a stable, representative government, and ensuring harmony among Syria’s grab bag of militias and external actors are herculean tasks. Jolani has played things well so far, but the real work begins now.
The U.S. and the rest of the international community should offer its support to HTS and the new government taking root in Damascus while also holding the group’s feet to the fire when it comes to distancing from jihadists and upholding human rights. But patience is also required: Under Assad’s rule — and particularly since the 2011 civil war began — Syria has experienced untold suffering. Large swathes of the country lie in ruins, and millions of refugees have fled their homes. The economy is in tatters, and the Syrian people are impoverished and hungry. The trauma of those imprisoned and tortured by Assad’s henchmen — or have seen firsthand the destruction wrought by his soldiers — is profound.
But after decades of darkness, the Syrian people are finally experiencing the first rays of freedom. The scenes on the streets of Damascus — and the elation of political prisoners freed from Assad’s hellish prisons — are wonderfully joyous. It is a moment for celebration and a reminder that the desire for freedom and recognition is unquenchable. Syria’s neighbors, along with the international community, must do everything they can to help the country stay on the right path.
Michael A. Cohen is a columnist for BLN and a senior fellow and co-director of the Afghanistan Assumptions Project at the Center for Strategic Studies at the Fletcher School, Tufts University. He writes the political newsletter Truth and Consequences. He has been a columnist at The Boston Globe, The Guardian and Foreign Policy, and he is the author of three books, the most recent being “Clear and Present Safety: The World Has Never Been Better and Why That Matters to Americans.”
The Dictatorship
‘This is a signal flare’: Swalwell reacts to Trump DOJ secretly seizing his phone records
-
‘Positively Orwellian’: Bombshell report reveals Trump DOJ spied on members of Congress
06:20
-
Now Playing
-
UP NEXT
‘This is insane’: Trump letting Elon Musk steal the spotlight
07:26
-
‘Enormous heist’: Hayes on the ‘audacious scheme’ to reward big donors
08:12
-
‘This is genocide’: Amnesty International accuses Israel of Gaza genocide
08:09
-
UnitedHealthcare CEO shooting: New evidence emerges on Day 2 of manhunt
05:29
-
‘Paranoid’: Trump FBI pick Kash Patel’s ‘truly wild’ beliefs unearthed
06:42
-
Manhunt continues after ‘targeted attack’ on UnitedHealthcare CEO
06:41
-
‘Do you have a problem with drinking?’: Hegseth faces new ‘jaw-dropping’ allegations
09:32
-
‘Reverse Jan. 6’: South Koreans help lawmakers scale parliament to save democracy
07:42
-
‘Buckle up, Buttercup’: Rep. Crockett sounds alarm over Trump economic agenda
06:54
-
Hayes: Remember the last time a country fooled around and found out?
07:52
-
Infighting roils Trump transition team: ‘The fish rots from the head’
08:04
-
Hayes: Overdose deaths are dropping. The reason why will surprise you.
06:34
-
‘Disgusting’: AOC eviscerates Republican rep’s trans bathroom stunt
02:48
-
‘Enraging’: Trump spawns ‘revenge for Me Too’ with Cabinet picks
11:29
-
Trump taps Florida’s Pam Bondi for AG after Matt Gaetz withdraws
08:08
-
Sen. Duckworth: I’d be worried about Hegseth ‘running a McDonalds,’ let alone the Pentagon
12:03
-
Bernie Sanders: No ‘blank check’ for Netanyahu
08:08
-
Bombshell NYT report reveals ‘trail of payments’ from Gaetz to women
06:33
-
‘Positively Orwellian’: Bombshell report reveals Trump DOJ spied on members of Congress
06:20
-
Now Playing
‘This is a signal flare’: Swalwell reacts to Trump DOJ secretly seizing his phone records
05:20
-
UP NEXT
‘This is insane’: Trump letting Elon Musk steal the spotlight
07:26
-
‘Enormous heist’: Hayes on the ‘audacious scheme’ to reward big donors
08:12
-
‘This is genocide’: Amnesty International accuses Israel of Gaza genocide
08:09
-
UnitedHealthcare CEO shooting: New evidence emerges on Day 2 of manhunt
05:29
The Dictatorship
Trump’s plan to rewrite the 14th Amendment has big implications for this subset of babies
In President-elect Donald Trump’s recent interview with NBC News’ Kristen Welkerhost of “Meet the Press,” he once again promised to end birthright citizenship when he takes office in January. “You know we’re the only country that has it,” Trump falsely claimed. While he flubbed many of the details about birthright citizenship, our focus should be on how radical a change it would truly be to no longer guarantee citizenship and its privileges to every child born in the United States. It’s a gutting of America’s promise that could only emerge from a purposeful, malicious and inherently cruel misreading of the Constitution.
It’s a gutting of America’s promise that could only emerge from a purposeful, malicious and inherently cruel misreading of the Constitution.
As the Trump campaign laid out over the summerthe proposed executive order he would sign would limit the scope of automatic citizenship to children born here and require at least one parent to prove they are either a U.S. citizen or a permanent resident. In the absence of such evidence, federal agencies would be ordered to deny the newborn from receiving a Social Security number and block the parents from receiving any federal benefits like the Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants and Childrenbetter known as WIC. That baby would also be denied a U.S. passport and any other documentary proof of citizenship.
Trump first pushed a similar change back in 2018but it got put far on the backburner by more cautious staffers. This time around, though, his incoming deputy chief of staff, Stephen Millerand other hard-liners are preparing to move forward with as many restrictions on immigration as possible. They subscribe to a worldview that has long rejected the notion that America’s white Christian heritage can stand while also freely accepting the children of nonwhite migrants or formerly enslaved Black people as equal citizens under the Constitution.
Miller’s fringe reading of the 14th Amendment becoming federal policy requires ignoring the amendment’s exceedingly plain language: “All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.” Trump hopes to add an asterisk to the clause and exclude potentially hundreds of thousands of babies each year. It would, in effect, transform those newborn U.S. citizens into undocumented aliens before they’ve completed their first day on Earth.
Trump’s campaign argued that the change is needed to deter illegal border crossings and prevent what’s derisively called “anchor babies” from acting as a backdoor for undocumented parents to remain. But the requirement would also exclude babies born to parents who are in the U.S. legally but aren’t permanent residents. Not only would that exclude babies born to those on temporary work or student visas, but it would also exclude babies born to those who’ve been admitted as refugees or granted political asylum.
America would be transformed from one of the most free and welcoming countries into a “blood and soil” nation of exclusion
In the latter case, asylees and refugees must wait a year before even applying to become a permanent resident. Even applying for and acquiring an employer-sponsored green card can take up to three years. And as best we can tell from what Trump’s team has said, babies born in the meantime wouldn’t be counted as citizens, no matter where in the application process their parents might be. Instead, there would now be a second-class tier of children who could be expelled with their parents as part of Trump’s promised mass deportations.
Tellingly, the way that the policy has been described suggests that Trump’s team has learned from the chaos of the 2017 “Muslim ban.” Rather than going for the most sweeping change possible, Miller and his cohorts have suggested a common-sense measure that would save taxpayers money, only affect children born to two undocumented parents and not be retroactive.
Even so, such a change will provoke a mountain of litigation almost immediately, and rightly so. It will be a hard sell even for the archconservative majority on the Supreme Court to overturn more than a century of precedent affirming that citizenship is granted at birth. But that won’t stop the right-wing ghouls from pushing for that to be overturned.
There’s a danger in even being willing to accept any exceptions in the notion that people born in the United States are citizens. It’s just a small step from there to requiring citizenship from one parent as a prerequisite; then both parents; then grandparents. America would be transformed from one of the most free and welcoming countries into a “blood and soil” nation of exclusion, one built on the backs of children whose only crime was being born under Trump’s second regime.
Hayes Brown is a writer and editor for BLN Daily, where he helps frame the news of the day for readers. He was previously at BuzzFeed News and holds a degree in international relations from Michigan State University.
The Dictatorship
‘Succession playing out in real life’: Fox News editorial future playing out in Murdoch family feud
-
Now Playing
-
UP NEXT
Report: Trump’s DOJ secretly obtained phone and text records from reporters and lawmakers
11:23
-
‘A fox guard the hen house’: Trump taps loyalist, Harmeet Dhillon to run DOJ civil rights division
09:45
-
Cheney, Kinzinger speak out after President Elect-Trump’s jail threat for Jan 6. Committee members
10:41
-
Nicolle Wallace: ‘Why’d the employee at McDonalds see him before any of his family or friends did?’
08:51
-
Valedictorian and Ivy League graduate named as person of interest in New York City CEO killing
07:46
-
‘Sink or swim’: Donald Trump unwilling to use any political capital to get Pete Hegseth confirmed
09:02
-
‘Dead man walking’: Trump’s scandal ridden nominee Pete Hegseth desperate to earn GOP Senate support
09:49
-
Nicolle Wallace on Hegseth: ‘Trump supports people in these situations 100 percent…until he doesn’t’
09:06
-
‘Secretary DeSanctimonius?’: Trump considering replacing Pete Hegseth with former enemy Ron DeSantis
07:54
-
‘The key to all this is Joni Ernst’: How one Republican Senator could tank Pete Hegseth’s nomination
07:31
-
‘Slow-motion train wreck’: Nicolle Wallace reacts to Pete Hegseth’s scandals
11:54
-
Michael Bloomberg slams Trump’s pick of RFK Jr. for Secretary of Health and Human Services
08:43
-
‘We needed to babysit him’: Pete Hegseth’s Fox News colleagues worried about his drinking
12:01
-
‘This isn’t the Fox and Friends couch’: Pete Hegseth set to face brutal confirmation process
11:59
-
How Donald Trump’s favorite children’s book author, Kash Patel got tapped to lead the FBI
11:07
-
How are we going to recruit people for this military?’: Claire McCaskill on Pete Hegseth
09:17
-
‘The disgust for Pete was pretty high’: Brutal new reporting on Trump’s pick for Defense Secretary
10:04
-
‘The courts are one part of it but it takes a national movement’: Fighting mass deportations
05:59
-
‘Absolutely, cruelty was the point’: Combating the shock value of Trump’s immigration policy
03:04
-
Now Playing
‘Succession playing out in real life’: Fox News editorial future playing out in Murdoch family feud
08:49
-
UP NEXT
Report: Trump’s DOJ secretly obtained phone and text records from reporters and lawmakers
11:23
-
‘A fox guard the hen house’: Trump taps loyalist, Harmeet Dhillon to run DOJ civil rights division
09:45
-
Cheney, Kinzinger speak out after President Elect-Trump’s jail threat for Jan 6. Committee members
10:41
-
Nicolle Wallace: ‘Why’d the employee at McDonalds see him before any of his family or friends did?’
08:51
-
Valedictorian and Ivy League graduate named as person of interest in New York City CEO killing
07:46
-
The Josh Fourrier Show1 month ago
DOOMSDAY: Trump won, now what?
-
Economy1 month ago
Fed moves to protect weakening job market with bold rate cut
-
Economy1 month ago
Harris dismisses Trump as ‘not serious’ on the economy in BLN interview
-
Congress1 month ago
Trump’s border czar promises ‘hell of a lot more’ deportations than first term
-
Health Care1 month agoAnti-abortion forces broke the left’s post-Roe winning streak, but 7 more states enacted protections
-
Health Care1 month ago
More abortion ballot measures are set to pass. Then state courts will have their say.
-
Politics1 month ago
Donald Trump has weaponized ‘main character energy’
-
Economy1 month ago
Biden touts economic gains, acknowledges a long way to go