The Dictatorship
How MTG could sabotage Elon Musk’s DOGE project before it has a chance
For decades, one of the most overpromised and underdelivered campaign pledges has been to reduce waste, fraud and abuse in government. Americans want to know that their tax dollars won’t be squandered and that their government will not spend $400 on a hammer.
A few weeks ago, President-elect Donald Trump announced the formation of a new advisory group called the Department of Government Efficiency, aka DOGE. Although its name suggests a government entity, DOGE will be an nongovernment commissionoperating independently. It will only be able to provide recommendations to the president and Congress, and like many of Trump’s early announcements, details about what it might do remain scarce.
There’s a long history of presidents tasking commissions with streamlining government.
We do know who will lead it, however: Elon Musk and Vivek Ramaswamy. According to Trump’s post on Xthe duo “will pave the way for my Administration to dismantle Government Bureaucracy, slash excess regulations, cut wasteful expenditures, and restructure Federal Agencies.” But due to Musk and Ramaswamy’s reputations — both have taken increasingly aggressive stances on social issues, prioritizing trolling and “own the libs” rhetoric — the reception from Democrats has been mostly pessimistic.
This is perhaps understandable. Trump’s return to the Oval Office has engendered an explosion of cynicism and distrust from many on the left. Trump’s various pledges to punish political opponents aren’t helping. Even so, Democrats need to try to fight against that cynicism — especially when it comes to the problems that politicians on both sides of the aisle can clearly see need fixing.
There’s a long history of presidents tasking commissions with streamlining government, leading to ideas that were both praised and panned. President Theodore Roosevelt’s Committee on Department Methods was tasked with investigating and reporting on “ways to improve business methods and practices of Executive departments” from 1905 to 1909. President Ronald Reagan created the Grace Commissionand President Bill Clinton formed the National Partnership for Reinventing Government. All had successes and less than stellar reviews.
Yes, the two men in charge of this most recent effort are flame throwers. I think Ramaswamy is mostly in this for the publicity and will likely fade away once he realizes how hard the work of meaningful government reform is. Candidly, former New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie nailed it a primary debate in 2023, when he called Ramaswamy “the most obnoxious blowhard in America.”
And many Democrats have significant political and policy differences with Musk. His systemic destruction of Xboosting of conspiratorial and antisemitic thinkingoffensive and at times dangerous jokes and attacks on free speech have won him few progressive friends. But I believe he is also brilliant. Perhaps he will have a unique way at viewing and finding areas of government that could truly use a reconfiguration.
For now, let’s ignore Musk’s unrealistic call for $2 trillion in budget cuts. He hasn’t even opened the books, and like Trump, has a habit of repeating misinformation.
When people outside of government look at how government is structured, shock is natural. But then the challenge begins. I don’t think it’s a bad thing for outsiders to be part of this process. New perspectives can help identify opportunities for innovation and improvement, while highlighting potential weaknesses.
And to be clear, Musk and Ramaswamy may find that maintaining the status quo is a very bipartisan practice. Every lawmaker has their favorite lobbyists and pet projects. But in a positive sign, some members of Congress are already signaling they will try to keep an open mind. Rep. Ro Khanna, D-Calif., who represents Silicon Valley, indicated there could be bi-partisan collaboration when looking at notoriously inefficient corners of government, like the defense budget.
More worrying to me is the dark cloud of Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene, R-Ga. After being removed from her committee assignments in 2021 for vile, hateful comments, Greene is poised to become the chairperson for a new subcommittee that will work with DOGE. Her involvement will make any collaboration between Musk and Democrats much more difficult. And there’s the risk that she will enable Musk’s and Ramaswamy’s worst impulses. In other words, she could be the biggest obstacle for a successful, bipartisan efficiency effort.
Will Musk be able to find ways to work with a Congress that too often defaults to partisan gridlock? We shall see. Restructuring parts of the federal government requires someone who knows how to build things, not just demolish them.
Susan Del Percio is a Republican strategist and a political analyst for NBC News and BLN.
The Dictatorship
Elon Musk says President Donald Trump has ‘agreed’ USAID should be shut down
WASHINGTON (AP) — The U.S. Agency for International Development is on the cusp of being shuttered, according the Trump administration’s billionaire adviser and Tesla CEO Elon Musk — who has been wrestling for control of the agency in recent days.
Early Monday, Musk held a live session on X Spaces, previously known as Twitter Spaces, and said that he spoke in detail about USAID with the president. “He agreed we should shut it down,” Musk said.
“It became apparent that its not an apple with a worm it in,” Musk said. “What we have is just a ball of worms. You’ve got to basically get rid of the whole thing. It’s beyond repair.” “We’re shutting it down.”
His comments come after the administration placed two top security chiefs at USAID on leave after they refused to turn over classified material in restricted areas to Musk’s government-inspection teams, a current and a former U.S. official told The Associated Press on Sunday.
Members of Musk’s Department of Government Efficiencyknown as DOGE, eventually did gain access Saturday to the aid agency’s classified information, which includes intelligence reports, the former official said.
Musk’s DOGE crew lacked high enough security clearance to access that information, so the two USAID security officials — John Voorhees and deputy Brian McGill — believed themselves legally obligated to deny access.
The current and former U.S. officials had knowledge of the incident and spoke on condition of anonymity because they were not authorized to share the information.
Musk on Sunday responded to an X post about the news by saying, “USAID is a criminal organization. Time for it to die.” He followed with additional posts on X about the aid agency.
Kate Miller, who serves on an advisory board for DOGE, said in a separate post that no classified material was accessed “without proper security clearances.”
It comes a day after DOGE carried out a similar operation at the Treasury Departmentgaining access to sensitive information including the Social Security and Medicare customer payment systems. The Washington Post reported that a senior Treasury official had resigned over Musk’s team accessing sensitive information.
Musk formed DOGE in cooperation with the Trump administration with the stated goal of finding ways to fire federal workerscut programs and slash federal regulations.
USAID, whose website vanished Saturday without explanation, has been one of the federal agencies most targeted by the Trump administration in an escalating crackdown on the federal government and many of its programs.
“It’s been run by a bunch of radical lunatics. And we’re getting them out,” Trump said to reporters about USAID on Sunday night.
The Trump administration and Secretary of State Marco Rubio have imposed an unprecedented freeze on foreign assistance that has shut down much of USAID’s humanitarian, development and security programs worldwide — compelling thousands of layoffs by aid organizations — and ordered furloughs and leaves that have gutted the agency’s leadership and staff in Washington.
The U.S. is by far the world’s largest donor of humanitarian aid, with USAID administering billions of dollars in humanitarian, development and security assistance in more than 100 countries.
Peter Marocco, a returning political appointee from Trump’s first term, was a leader in enforcing the shutdown. USAID staffers say they believe that agency outsiders with visitors badges asking questions of employees inside the Washington headquarters are members of Musk’s DOGE team.
Democratic Sen. Elizabeth Warren said in a post on Sunday that Trump was allowing Musk to access people’s personal information and shut down government funding.
“We must do everything in our power to push back and protect people from harm,” the Massachusetts senator said, without giving details.
___
Associated Press writers Michelle L. Price in New York, Matthew Lee in Panama City and Fatima Hussein in Washington contributed to this report.
___ This story has been updated to correct the surname name of one of the USAID security officials. He is John Voorhees, not John Vorhees.
The Dictatorship
‘Serial disappointer’ Sen. Collins indicates she’ll vote for Tulsi Gabbard
-
Trump pauses tariffs on Canada and Mexico; China hits back at U.S. tariffs
14:25
-
‘One of the coolest gigs a comedian can get’: Amber Ruffin tapped for WHCA dinner
05:30
-
Julia Stiles makes directorial debut with ‘Wish You Were Here’
07:19
-
Steve Rattner: Trump’s tariffs disrupt the markets
03:12
-
Trump, Netanyahu set to discuss ongoing ceasefire today at White House
05:49
-
Not confident Trump will prevail: Scholar on his attempts to take Congress’ power of the purse
11:47
-
Now Playing
-
UP NEXT
Rahm Emanuel on fears of FBI purge: This will not play out well
11:43
-
‘This makes America less safe’: Growing fears of Trump WH FBI purge
11:01
-
‘The whole thing is nuts’: Writer reacts to defrocked priest imitating Musk’s salute
06:26
-
USAID staffers told to stay out of D.C. headquarters after Musk said Trump agreed to close it
10:52
-
Crews to remove wreckage from Potomac today
08:13
-
Joe: When you gut USAID, the big winners are those that wish the U.S. harm
14:06
-
‘Utter madness’: Canadian PM candidate slams Trump’s tariffs
08:17
-
Dow futures drop more than 650 points after Trump hits U.S. trading partners with tariffs
03:26
-
Gabbard ‘stumbled through her hearing’ Thursday, says Rep. Himes
04:41
-
Trump tariffs could take effect tomorrow
04:30
-
‘Anti-safety agenda’: Trump went race-baiting route because of cuts, senator suggests
11:28
-
Families mourn 67 victims after midair collision
03:27
-
Tom Costello: Army helicopter’s black box will be critical in investigation
08:47
-
UP NEXT
Trump pauses tariffs on Canada and Mexico; China hits back at U.S. tariffs
14:25
-
‘One of the coolest gigs a comedian can get’: Amber Ruffin tapped for WHCA dinner
05:30
-
Julia Stiles makes directorial debut with ‘Wish You Were Here’
07:19
-
Steve Rattner: Trump’s tariffs disrupt the markets
03:12
-
Trump, Netanyahu set to discuss ongoing ceasefire today at White House
05:49
-
Not confident Trump will prevail: Scholar on his attempts to take Congress’ power of the purse
11:47
The Dictatorship
There’s a lot of craziness in D.C. right now. But you can safely ignore these stunts.
When I took a job years ago managing a website about Congress, I was shocked to discover that the most-searched bill was an obscure piece of legislation called the Blair Holt Act.
The bill, which would require gun licenses and background checks, was going nowhere. It had two sponsors in the House — one of whom was a nonvoting member representing the Virgin Islands. It didn’t have a companion bill in the Senate. It was what people in Washington call a “messaging bill” designed to signal to voters that the lawmaker takes a particular issue seriously. But every month, it was at the top of our Google Analytics.
In this case, the bill had inadvertently provoked another group of voters — gun owners who believed the Blair Holt Act was the first sign that the government was coming for their firearms. They were sharing the legislation on message boards and in conspiracy theory-minded emails, panicking over a bill that was never going to be signed into law.
As the president has signed executive orders right and left, some lawmakers seem to feel left out.
Now this dynamic is playing out in a novel fashion in President Donald Trump’s chaotic first two weeks in office. Normally members of Congress reserve messaging bills for closer to the next election. But as the president has signed executive orders right and left, some lawmakers seem to feel left out. They’re turning to messaging bills earlier to draw attention and getting more extreme than we’ve seen in the past. The worst of these aren’t so much messaging bills as the legislative equivalent of what people euphemistically call “trashposting” on the internet. And some of the president’s critics are falling for it.
In January, Rep. Anna Paulina Luna, R-Fla., filed a bill to direct the interior secretary to “arrange for the carving of the figure of President Donald J. Trump on Mount Rushmore.” The bill, which has no co-sponsors, was dutifully referred to a House committee, where it will die a quiet death. But in the meantime, Trump might hear about it and think nicely of Luna, or she can tout it on social media posts about triggering the libs.
That same month, Rep. Andy Ogles, R-Tenn., proposed a constitutional amendment to allow presidents to serve third terms — as long as their other two terms weren’t consecutive, a loophole that appears designed to give Trump a pass while keeping, say, Barack Obama, on the sidelines.
The bill, which also has zero co-sponsors, is about as serious as the Mount Rushmore proposal. If anything, it’s an even heavier lift than carving into the side of a mountain in South Dakota. A constitutional amendment requires approval by two-thirds of both chambers and ratification by three-fourths of states. That’s just not going to happen, much less in time for an 82-year-old Trump to run again in 2028.
In Ogles’ case, he might have another motive for trying to score points with Trump. A week after he filed his bill, federal prosecutors in Nashville withdrew from a criminal investigation into why Ogles misrepresented how much money he lent his campaign on federal forms. That case will now be handled entirely from the Justice Department’s Washington headquarters, which Trump has vowed to exert more control over.
Other lawmakers seem emboldened by Trump’s dramatic proposals to remake the federal government, and, to be honest, it’s understandable if the average voter can’t tell if they are serious or not. Here are a few more examples:
Rep. Andy Biggs of Arizona proposed a bill to abolish the Occupational Safety and Health Administration, which handles workplace safety (no co-sponsors).
Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene of Georgia proposed two bills to “expunge” Trump’s first-term impeachments (10 co-sponsors each).
And Rep. Earl “Buddy” Carter of Georgia proposed a bill to abolish the IRS and enact a national sales tax (11 co-sponsors).
These bills aren’t going to pass. They’re interesting as a sign of the current thinking among the outer reaches of today’s Republican Party, but you don’t need to ever think about them again.
Amid the uncertainty of Trump’s second term, it’s important to take a breath, check the sources and make sure we’re not getting riled up over a messaging bill going nowhere. First, is it dramatic and easy to explain? Second, does it have almost no co-sponsors? If the answer to both questions is yes, then it’s a trashposting bill.
There are a lot of unnerving things going on in Washington these days. It’s important to save your attention — and your outrage — for the ones that are real.
Ryan Teague Beckwith is a newsletter editor for BLN. He has previously worked for such outlets as Time magazine, Bloomberg News and CQ Roll Call. He teaches journalism at Georgetown University’s School of Continuing Studies.
-
The Josh Fourrier Show3 months ago
DOOMSDAY: Trump won, now what?
-
Economy3 months ago
Fed moves to protect weakening job market with bold rate cut
-
Economy3 months ago
It’s still the economy: What TV ads tell us about each campaign’s closing message
-
Economy3 months ago
Harris dismisses Trump as ‘not serious’ on the economy in BLN interview
-
Politics3 months ago
Donald Trump wants Americans to hate Kamala Harris — but he’s failing
-
Economy3 months ago
Biden touts economic gains, acknowledges a long way to go
-
Politics3 months ago
RFK Jr.’s bid to take himself off swing state ballots may scramble mail-in voting
-
Politics3 months ago
Democrats express concern over Gaetz pick